4 ms·
Yes, but the temperature rose to those levels over millenia, not just hundreds of years. Ultimately, life on Earth will adapt - it's just that we might not surv
by gambiting 7y ago
Yes, but the temperature rose to those levels over millenia, not just hundreds of years. Ultimately, life on Earth will adapt - it's just that we might not survive long enough to witness the adaptation.
- pdonis 7y ago> the temperature rose to those levels over millenia, not just hundreds of years We don't actually know that. The time resolution of the data is not good enough to tell us. It's quite possible that it happened faster in the past as well. > we might not survive long enough to witness the adaptation Quite honestly, I don't understand why people think our ability to adapt is so poor. We already have more than 5 C variation in average temperature across different regions of Earth, yet people adapt to living in all of those different regions. Also, all the alarmist rhetoric about the supposed impacts of changes in temperature is not based on actual knowledge or on models with demonstrated predictive power. It's based on very crude extrapolations of trends that assume that people will do nothing at all to adapt. In other words, they assume people won't adapt and then complain that we can't adapt. What's more, the two main things we can do to adapt are things we should be doing anyway: (1) bring more people out of poverty--the richer people are the easier they can adapt to change; and (2) make our infrastructure more robust. The second, in particular, is exactly what "green energy" should be marketed as--making energy more decentralized, which makes the entire system more robust. And doing those things benefits us regardless of what kind of change happens--whether it's climate change or any other kind of change.
- partialrecall 7y ago> "The time resolution of the data is not good enough to tell us." Is that actually true? What's the sampling rate and subsequent Nyquist frequency? It's my impression that the sampling rate given by ice core samples is surprisingly high (something in the neighborhood of year-by-year.)
- pdonis 7y ago> It's my impression that the sampling rate given by ice core samples is surprisingly high (something in the neighborhood of year-by-year.) Ice cores only cover hundreds of thousands of years into the past (I think the oldest is about 800,000 years). I'm talking about times millions of years ago.
- yes-except-no 7y agoCongratulations, you are part of the problem :) This type of answer is on par with "The earth won't die, only humans, the earth will be fine!". That's great, but we're kinda focusing on humans, and being pedantic will not help the situation. 1/ Temperatures raising by 5 degrees in europe, or midwest US will mean droughts, because many of the plants we cultivate will not have the time to adapt and will plain die. 2/ The "alarmist" rethoric has been held back every time, because people like you would say that scientists are exaggerating. Exxon predictions from the 70s are being confirmed. Every single study that you read in journals for the past ten years about climate change only shows the lowest bound, because people cannot handle urgency. And every single time, without fail, it reaches the higher bound or worse. 3/ People won't adapt because people will _die_. We're not talking small deaths. We're talking tens of thousands because of heat waves, millions due to famine. When half of Africa is going to be knocking at Europe's doorstep because their countries are becoming inhabitable, do you think everything will be smooth? 4/ Bringing more people out of poverty has been the main reason why we're in such a crazy state of things. Yes, China has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty, and I'm glad. But at what cost? 5/ So, your solution is to say fuck it, it's gonna change, keep driving SUVs and make Earth a living hell, we're gonna adapt anyways. People will _die_ from such ways of thinking. Hope your conscience won't be too bothered.
- dahdum 7y agoI'm curious how you picture the scenarios in which humanity doesn’t survive even +10F average over the next 200 years? Let’s also say a population of several billion. I see the sentiment often, even in journalism, and I don’t see a realistic path even absent the inevitable new technology.
- gambiting 7y agoRight, so I don't think we would completely die out. As always with almost any catastrophe, there would always be small pockets of humans surviving somewhere and I think it's reasonable to say they would rebuild eventually. I'm just thinking that if the oxygen levels drop a few percent that won't kill us, but it will start affecting our cognitive levels - so I'm imagining that those who can afford it will just carry portable oxygen bottles with them. Offices/homes will be equipped with oxygen disperses through the ventilation systems, just so we can feel "normal". I imagine that would cause massive unrest with people who cannot afford this. But hey, this is just speculation. Maybe we will find a technological solution long before this happens.