5 ms·
Just ban all personal cars from city centers, replace every 5 banned cars with 1 electric taxi and make it free for people with a public transportation subscrip
by lm28469 7y ago
Just ban all personal cars from city centers, replace every 5 banned cars with 1 electric taxi and make it free for people with a public transportation subscription.
Boom, every single "cars in city" problems solved. I'm sure that even with 100% state subsidised taxi rides it would still be a net positive if you consider costs of health, pollution, accidents, insurances, &c.
- rubbingalcohol 7y agoWhat if 5 people want to go to different places at the same time?
- ollie87 7y agoDoesn't have to be 5, you would model it and adjust.
- dagw 7y agoThen you'll just end up introducing more and more taxis until you're back to where you started.
- lm28469 7y agoYou'll never get back where you started since most cars are parked in front of an office / house / whatever 95% of the time using space for no reason whereas taxis are always moving.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoWhat you gain in parking, you lose in congestion. Now most trips are 'deadheading' where the trip to pick up the passenger is as long as the trip the passenger wants to take. Doubles traffic, approximately?
- em-bee 7y agoi think this was even discussed here at HN some time ago, in some cities it apparently was cheaper to drive a car in circles than to pay for parking.
- UnpossibleJim 7y agoThere was, when the mention of Tesla's auto pilot was being discussed, I believe.
- dagw 7y agowhereas taxis are always moving. Moving cars are the problem, since they are what causes congestion and accidents. Cars sitting in parking garages don't run over people or cause traffic jams.
- adrianN 7y agoIn Berlin most cars sit on the road not in parking garages, blocking two lanes of every street.
- lm28469 7y agoThey wait 10 min instead of moving a cumulated 10 tons of steel to displace 250kg of meat. I know, "that's insane!", right ?
- rubbingalcohol 7y agoIt's not "insane," just poorly thought out.
- lm28469 7y ago> poorly thought out. Compared to dumping metric tons of toxic gases and particles right next to where we live/work/sleep as well as moving 2 tons vehicles to displace 1 person ? Using 50% of the streets to park cars that move 30 min per days ? Just because we're used to something doesn't make it less insanely dumb. ICE / personal cars would never be allowed if created today.
- rubbingalcohol 7y agoI sympathize. I commute on a bike and wish more people would do it. The reality, however, is that cities are built around personal transportation being a thing. What you've suggested is just shoehorning something in (centralized government-run personal transportation) apparently without any thought of how it would actually impact commute time traffic, or whether other infrastructure enhancements would be more ideal. For public transit to work it has to scale to the number of people who actually need it. In most cities it does not. Adding electric taxis at a ratio of 1 to 5 commuters makes absolutely zero sense. Adding electric taxis at a ratio of 5 to 5 commuters still makes no sense. It's just a dumb idea.
- lm28469 7y agoWe both can't backup our claims with real data but I feel like what we have right now is the worst possible solution in almost every aspects. Personal cars, personal insurances, personal parking spots, none of that make sense. It's a massive waste of resource, money and space that has a gigantic effect on everyone living in a city. It would also be a huge incentive for people to start looking into other types of transportation.
- em-bee 7y agothe comparison is 10000 people going to 10000 different places vs 10000 people going to 2000 different places. i can't say which number is realistic, but i think it is safe to say that the number of destinations is less than the number of people traveling.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThey just wait longer and spend more times on their phones waiting.
- bakuninsbart 7y agoThis is definetely the way to move forward, but here in Berlin it would be political suicide for now. The steps to take (some of which are already being taken): - Introduce good bike lanes, narrowing down streets. Give bikes more priority in traffic rules (can't really be done in Berlin since they are federal rules). - Introduce an inner city car toll. Offset losses to businesses that absolutely require it through tax breaks. (construction, delivery drivers, taxis etc.) - Close down non-essential streets completely during most hours (4-6am free for deliveries etc.). Reduce parking/make drivers pay for parking. At the same time, you need to make it easier for people to switch: - Reduce prices of public transport for residents. In Berlin they want to introduce a yearly ticket for 365€, that is perfect. - Increase availability of public transport, and make all busses electric. - Introduce large parking spaces at key points in the far suburbs of the city. Parking there costs a fee that also works as a day ticket for public transport. Express busses take you to the city centre/other key infrastructure points. Some of these are already being worked on in Berlin, otherwise I know are on the agenda and being discussed. In Berlin specifically though, some points might not be legal. Inner city toll for example might be prohibited by federal law. E: One important point I forgot: Cars account for 25% of all emissions in Berlin. On the local level, getting rid of cars is the best thing we can do to combat climate change.
- lm28469 7y ago> This is definetely the way to move forward, but here in Berlin it would be political suicide for now. It's definitely a political suicide in most cities in the world, but it's probably the best way to get out of the madness we lowered ourselves into while retaining most of the mobility. I agree with everything you listed.
- turk73 7y agoI think probably disconnecting all the electricity would also be a solid move.
- thrav 7y agoI definitely felt like Berlin was way behind Paris on bike lane quality, but I did appreciate the number of intersections that have been half blocked by pillars, to make streets less conducive to any other kind of through traffic. I rented a Vespa while I was there, which was a great way to get around, but I was blown away by how many times cars sped by me in a hurry from behind. It’s rare to ever see a car get going >30mph (~50kph) in San Francisco, whereas some Berlin streets felt more like freeways. I wouldn’t have enjoyed being on a bicycle in some of those situations.
- odiroot 7y ago> Just ban all personal cars from city centers, replace every 5 banned cars with 1 electric taxi This wouldn't help, as I mentioned in another comment here. Taxi drivers are one of the most dangerous, obnoxious and self-absorbed drivers in this town. Also the city mulls over increasing the base rates for taxis which are already prohibitively expensive.
- lm28469 7y ago> Taxi drivers are one of the most dangerous, obnoxious and self-absorbed drivers in this town. When they compete for fares in saturated markets, yeah sure. Not if they get proper salaries and are employed by the city/state.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sliken 7y agoSo then there will be headlines about people getting run down by electric taxis instead?
- dagw 7y agoreplace every 5 banned cars with 1 electric taxi and make it free That will massively increase the number of cars on the roads city center. Most cars in cities spend most of their time parked. Offer a free taxi service and those cars will be rolling 24/7. Plus since the service will be so popular that there will basically always be someone waiting for a ride, drivers will be incentivized to driver faster so that they can get more fares (and thus more money).
- UIZealot 7y agoIf the taxi service is free, there will be no fares, and no incentive to drive faster.
- majewsky 7y agoThere would still be incentive to drive faster. Given that the service has a fixed income side, the only way to optimize its profitability is getting the expense side down. Driving faster to make more tours with less cars is the most obvious way to do this, therefore drivers will be incentivized to go faster.
- adrianN 7y agoI don't see how replacing five cars with one massively increases the number of cars.
- Retric 7y agoon the roads != in the city People don’t spend very long driving their cars in the center of cities.
- aidenn0 7y agoIf a typical car spends more than 80% of its time parked, then the math works out.
- adrianN 7y agoIf people who would have driven their own car now take a taxi instead the math doesn't work out unless the taxis have to drive five times the average trip length for making pickups.
- taffer 7y agoI don't like this idea of "free car rides" at all, I believe it would actually make things worse. There is a cost vs. convenience trade off between public transport and cars, i. e. public transport is much cheaper, but you have to walk the last mile. Making cars as cheap as public transport would destroy the incentive to use public transport and most people would switch to car travel instead. Also, as others have pointed out, cars are parked most of the time (like 95% of the day), so replacing 5 cars with 1 taxi is unlikely to lead to a reduction, combined with the new incentive (see above) to use cars instead of bikes, buses, trains, etc., most of the problems involved would actually get worse.