3 ms·
Caffeine can decrease anxiety? That's highly contradictory to a bulk of medical wisdom out there. "Medicinal plants contain a wide array of chemical compounds.
by Alex3917 16y ago
Caffeine can decrease anxiety? That's highly contradictory to a bulk of medical wisdom out there.
"Medicinal plants contain a wide array of chemical compounds. At first, this looks like chaos, but more investigation reveals a distinct order. Natural selection pressures push a plant to "try out" variations on molecules to enhance the plant's odds of surviving stressful environments. So, often, one molecule is present in the greatest amount and has the most dramatic effect in a human body -- but along with it are variations of that molecule in the same plant.
For example, for several years, I did ethnobotanical study in South America, researching native uses for coca leaf, which most of us know only as the source of the isolated, problematic, addictive drug cocaine. For Andean Indians, whole coca leaf is the number one medicinal plant. They use it to treat gastrointestinal disturbances; specifically, for both diarrhea and constipation. From the perspective of Western pharmacology, this makes no sense. Cocaine stimulates the gut, it increases bowel activity, so obviously it would be a good treatment for constipation, but what could it do for diarrhea except make it worse?
However, if you look carefully at the coca leaf's molecular array, you find 14 bioactive alkaloids, with cocaine in the greatest amount. While cocaine acts as a gut stimulant, other coca alkaloids can have precisely the opposite action, they inhibit gut activity.
This means that when you take the whole mixture into the body, the potential is there for the action to go in either direction. What decides it? The state of the body, which is a function of which receptors in the gut's tissues are available for binding. During my time in Andean Indian communities, I collected many reports about whole coca's paradoxical, normalizing effect on bowel function, and experienced it firsthand, as well."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/andrew-weil-md/why-plants-are-usually-be_b_785139.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/andrew-weil-md/why-plants-are-...
- wanderr 16y agoVery interesting. Thanks for sharing!
- mhd 16y agoAndrew Weil isn't exactly regarded as the most credible source in medical circles. (And I'm being kind here. I've heard some comparisons to Deepak Chopra…)
- Alex3917 16y agoHe's pretty up on his science. Don't forget he graduated from Harvard medical school, was editor of the Crimson, and majored in botany as an undergrad, making him probably vastly smarter and more knowledgeable about science than anyone here on HN. I actually saw him give a talk this year where he talked about how LSD cured his cat allergies: http://www.maps.org/videos/source/video6.html http://www.maps.org/videos/source/video6.html He speculates about a lot of stuff like this that sounds pretty crazy unless you're willing to take the time to understand his argument. Obviously these kinds of musings are unproven, but that is by definition the nature of speculation. And his actual medical advice is all pretty solid from what I've seen. My favorite talk by him is this: http://www.matrixmasters.net/salon/?p=129 http://www.matrixmasters.net/salon/?p=129 Again there is a lot of speculation, but there's nothing wrong with that at least in my book.
- nollidge 16y ago> vastly smarter and more knowledgeable about science than anyone here on HN Perhaps, but that's probably why the GP talked about his reputation "in medical circles". He's not any more knowledgeable about science than his major critics: http://www.quackwatch.com/11Ind/weil.html http://www.quackwatch.com/11Ind/weil.html http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2008/06/science_is_irrelevant_resistance_is_futi.php http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2008/06/science_is_irrelev... http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=4431 http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=4431 http://scientopia.org/blogs/whitecoatunderground/2009/10/18/the-wild-weil-world-of-woo/ http://scientopia.org/blogs/whitecoatunderground/2009/10/18/...
- Alex3917 16y agoThe quackwatch article you cite is extremely intellectually dishonest. It makes a couple points which would be interesting if true, but the overwhelming about of BS makes me highly skeptical. The author seems to have a complete inability to just point out any errors Weil has made and explain why they are wrong. Instead we get sentences like: "The leaders of the establishment believe in the scientific method, and in the rule of evidence, and in the laws of physics, chemistry, and biology upon which the modern view of nature is based. Alternative practitioners either do not seem to care about science or explicitly reject its premises." Not only is this intellectually dishonest because it has nothing to do with what Weil has actually written, but it isn't even true; it was homeopathy that invented evidence-based medicine and drug testing in the first place.