5 ms·
The corruption is in both people being forced into unreasonable costs for healthcare and the state failing to provide a good recourse for persons in debt this d
by munk-a 7y ago
The corruption is in both people being forced into unreasonable costs for healthcare and the state failing to provide a good recourse for persons in debt this deep.
- rayiner 7y agoPolicies you happen to disagree with are not “corruption.”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ASalazarMX 7y agoWhat do you call this then? Fraud? > The $164,000 billed to Waldron for intestinal surgery was more than twice what a commercial insurer would have paid for her care [..]. Charges on her bill included $2,000 for a $20 feeding tube.
- CptFribble 7y agoIf that price was arrived at by an official process and properly documented, then that's the system working as intended. The questions is, intended by whom?
- geggam 7y agoSo with careful planning and proper documentation you can rob a bank ? Intent is a serious factor in crime.
- rs23296008n1 7y agoEssentially, yes. Please familiarise yourself with sub-prime mortgages and 2007 - 2009. With the right kind of paperwork you can not only rob a bank you can also make yourself a beneficiary of multiple bailouts and benefits. With even better paperwork you then claim the losses as part of lowering your tax obligation.
- geggam 7y agoIs it theft if you steal QE ? I mean... is it really there ?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vonmoltke 7y agoI call it price gouging, which is not corruption. How is it corruption?
- mindslight 7y agoThe corruption is how the courts actually enforce these funny money debts rather than doing the right thing and dismissing them. Barring a proper contract (which the sheer majority of these outrageous bills inherently lack), the basis for owing the debt is unjust enrichment. But that means a patient should at most be paying the lower of the medicare/medicaid/insurance negotiated prices - it shouldn't be a license for the hospital to simply make up any number and play poker. I don't think we definitively need single payer, but we do need uniform (per provider) pricing and price transparency. (Although allowing everyone to buy into medicare/medicaid would be a no-brainer) Barring systematic reform, I'd really like to see a trend of "healthcare extortion trusts" to keep everyone's life savings safe from these vampires.
- deathanatos 7y ago> Barring a proper contract, the basis for owing the debt is unjust enrichment. And I want to add to this: patients can't even be held at fault for this: have no ability to even find out! I've asked and asked for this up front (after being hit myself with a huge bill for what was a tiny visit! No surgery, just an examination!), and been told by providers that it is "impossible" to provide even an estimate of a price, even when the provider has all of my insurance information. Which is bullshit. To make a patient choose between an unknown bill and their health is extortion.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> The corruption is how the courts actually enforce these funny money debts rather than doing the right thing and dismissing them. How is that corruption? Who is being corrupted, and by whom? The state cannot corrupt itself.
- mindslight 7y ago
- rayiner 7y agoFraud is where you lie about a material fact to induce someone to give you some benefit. Where is the fraud here?
- mindslight 7y agoThe lie is the fictitious "list price" on the bill, which is nowhere near the amount generally paid nor agreed upon beforehand. Let's say I'm going out and offer to bring you back a sandwich. I can't give you the sandwich and then claim you owe me $20 because that was my price. I either need to form that contract up front, or I can only expect reimbursement for the amount I actually paid.
- jascii 7y agoBy itself not, no.. However if you figure in how said policies came to be, looking at for instance the amount of money the "healthcare industry" spends on lobbying, then the term "corruption" seems not unreasonable.
- vonmoltke 7y agoThis is completely a state issue. How is industry lobbying relevant? What are they lobbying for? More profits for the State of Virginia?
- vonmoltke 7y agoSo, is anybody going to actually answer the questions?
- jascii 7y agoThe reasons people end up with medical debt(being underinsured, etc) are absolutely not a state issue and directly related to industry lobbying.
- vonmoltke 7y agoI thought we were talking about the extortionate bills from this state-run hospital. What does lobbying have to do with that? Also, at the risk of not getting that question answered, what does lobbying have to do with people being underinsured?
- munk-a 7y agoThe general walled garden existence of health care providers - the incredible disparity between list prices for procedures (the "chargemaster") and the cost to deliver those procedures including labour and parts - these are some entrenched business that lobby the government to establish a broken healthcare system, but it isn't everything! You also need to look at PBMs that eek out a living as a middleman between pharma companies and insurers and survive by bulk offering pharmaceutical consumption in exchange for rebates while advocating for higher pre-insured prices to maximize the price difference between direct purchasing and their rebate reduced price. You _also_ need to look at health insurers that operate in pretty much the same manner as PBMs but with everything that isn't a drug, highers list prices at hospitals coupled with lower negotiated rates for their patients is why a person with good insurance may pay 130$ for a 13k list price procedure, and the people with bad insurance are hit with the full cost. Lastly the siloing of patients to specific care networks gives healthcare providers better control over how much that after insurance take-home is for themselves, if there are three hospitals within a few hours of you but two are out of network and the last one won't give you upfront information about their pricing then you have no freedom to choose efficiently. Oh also, the pharma companies, they've gotten a bad rap recently for opiods. But it's a generally policy that drug reps that monetarily reward doctors for prescribing certain volumes of medication without any relation to patient needs, thus driving up the unnecessary usage of medication (and the cost to insurers, and the cut of PBMs) while also potentially causing further health issues from side effects of a drug the person didn't need in the first place. Everything in this system is broken and it's basically just a carousel of terrible where each pillar is supporting the other ones because everyone is making so much damn money - and politicians are happy to force any state offerings to play by the same rules for a share of that cash for themselves. In a sane system without the lobbying and corruption this cartel of players would be unsustainable because public interest would force politicians to cut down on their crap, but that ain't happening. And, while I think some intents of the law were decent, the actual effect of the ACA has been to cement the improper running of this market into law while forcing absolutely everyone into insurance - the ACA was a huge gift to insurers and it, and the private insurance and healthcare market that spawned it, need to be nationalized.