4 ms·
Don't subsidize for profit companies. Subsidies are a transfer of tax payer money to a company. If a company is turning a profit while receiving subsidies, it
by olliej 7y ago
Don't subsidize for profit companies.
Subsidies are a transfer of tax payer money to a company. If a company is turning a profit while receiving subsidies, it is simply a transfer of tax payer money to business owners.
- andrekandre 7y agoi think this is what people mean when they say "corporate socialism"?
- pmiller2 7y agoIt’s typically called “corporate welfare,” but, yes.
- mschuster91 7y agoThere are multiple kinds of subsidies, it's not as simple: 1) Walmart (or other) companies pay so low wages that employees are eligible for food stamps or other subsidies. This is utterly outrageous and should be a criminal offense - at least, states should be allowed to claw back the assistance costs plus a 200% fine from the company to discourage this behavior. 2) Environmental subsidies: Government pays subsidies to companies (or private persons) to install new environmentally-friendly technology which is (thanks to being new) too expensive from an ROI viewpoint. Germany did this with solar and basically kickstarted the market for home solar, USA did the same with the incentives for Tesla and other e-vehicles. Obviously, these subsidies are fine as they lead to further savings or environmental goals down the road. 3) Government gives tax breaks to companies for relocation/creating new business: these are the most contested probably as multinational entities (hello Amazon) often enough abuse them for their own profit only. Done right, however, this form of subsidies has a positive ROI as a new business pays local taxes as well as its workers, who additionally provide purchasing power in their communities.
- closeparen 7y ago>1) Walmart (or other) companies pay so low wages that employees are eligible for food stamps or other subsidies. This is utterly outrageous and should be a criminal offense - at least, states should be allowed to claw back the assistance costs plus a 200% fine from the company to discourage this behavior. It's cheaper for the taxpayer to supplement a low wage than to provide for someone with no wage.
- mschuster91 7y ago> It's cheaper for the taxpayer to supplement a low wage than to provide for someone with no wage. The private owners of Walmart extract profit, but refuse to provide their workers with a wage they can survive (!!!) on. The point of social welfare programs is to help those in need, not to help profitable businesses make even more profits.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWhat GP is saying is Walmart aren't likely to start paying a worker fairly, they're more likely to just fire them and get someone even more desperate. Food stamps are awful but for now it's better than people going hungry. In the meantime there needs to be solutions, they're a temporary fix at best.
- closeparen 7y agoWelfare budget that we invest in spiting private owners is then no longer available for making net improvements for people in need. Any government service saves businesses from having to pay workers enough to buy that service in the market. That’s usually a good thing for all involved. We don’t complain that public schools are a subsidy to employers who would otherwise pay enough for private school tuition.
- murderfs 7y ago> This is utterly outrageous and should be a criminal offense - at least, states should be allowed to claw back the assistance costs plus a 200% fine from the company to discourage this behavior. Alternatively, instead of raising the minimum wage in a dumb and opaque way, the state could just raise the minimum wage instead? Why is it better for a local mom and pop grocery store to pay their employees garbage than for Walmart to do it?
- mschuster91 7y agoI'm all for minimum wage, the problem is that cost-of-living is vastly different across states - make a universal US or state wide minimum wage and it will be too low in some areas and too high in others, and a regional minimum wage, while better, will be politicized as hell, plus it creates an incentive for local businesses to bribe or otherwise manipulate politicians to lower the minimum wage. I'm not sure if there is a one-size-fits-all solution.
- donatj 7y ago> 1) Walmart (or other) companies pay so low wages that employees are eligible for food stamps or other subsidies. How would you compare that to simply not offering the job at all? For a lot of low paying jobs, that’s the deal. Asking a company to pay more for labor than said labor increases profits is unreasonable. These jobs just largely wouldn’t be offered. The same people would still end up on subsidies and don’t get any work experience. I’d argue it’s a worse result.
- Joe8Bit 7y agoThere's no real evidence that's true. There are lots of countries where minimum wage policies are providing (or exceeding) a living wage for their employees[0]. At least enough for their employees to feed themselves without government assistance. None of these countries have a demonstrable lack of employment growth[0] at the low end, and in macro and micro economic terms have comparable growth with the US. [0]: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/DDN-20190131-2 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/D... [1]: https://data.oecd.org/emp/employment-rate.htm https://data.oecd.org/emp/employment-rate.htm
- donatj 7y agoThe European economy is different in many ways, closer to home we’ve seen slashed hours [0] resulting in workers getting less overall take home pay, as well as increased prices. Not only did it result in the poor making less but the cost of living went up. [0]: https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle-minimum-wage-15-dollars https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle...
- markmark 7y agoThat article doesn't seem to say what you claim it says?
- donatj 7y ago> They found that the policy “reduced hours worked in low-wage jobs by 6-7 percent, while hourly wages in such jobs increased by 3 percent ... consequently, total payroll for such jobs decreased.” That means the total amount that employers paid to workers was less with the new minimum wage in place than projected payroll if the policy hadn’t gone into effect. Also > Surveying employers, Romich and other researchers found the most common response to the wage increase was to raise prices
- DrScientist 7y agoTo some other areas - someone else picking up the tab for externalities that are not properly priced. For example: - public funded infrastructure which company relies on for business but doesn't pay for through tax - eg roads. - environmental dumping - C02, pollution, waste where the full economic cost is paid down the line by future generations - in effect a subsidy on today's activities. The other main area is to maintain 'strategic capabilities' - food production, defence, energy. There was an interesting example in the UK - combining both energy and defence: rumour has it that the UK government approved a new nuclear powerplant not so much on it's merits, but on the worry that if there wasn't a domestic nuclear industry in the UK, then the military would face a nuclear skills gap.
- rjf72 7y agoI used to agree with you on #1 whole heartedly. It's a point I brought up many many times. But this is an issue that is not as simple as it seems. Because the catch is that employees are different. In particular a single adult working at minimum wage for 40 hours a week is not going to qualify for much in the way of public assistance. However, somebody who has 6 children at home would receive money from the government that would be some multiple of their salary. From WalMart's perspective any two employees are, more or less, the same. But that's what also leads to headlines like governments subsidizing WalMarts by $x billion. The issue is that WalMart could bring down this subsidy to basically $0 by only hiring employees who aren't having children while working minimum wage jobs (now $11/hour). Of course this is probably not the path you want to go down. Basically the issue is a lot more complex than the numbers, in isolation, would suggest. And it comes alongside fundamental questions about society, funding, motivations, and more. In particular it's effectively a proxy for 'should employers be required to pay employees who have children more money for the same work'? I've no idea the answer to that question. It's extremely complex and comes with numerous issues. In any case I suspect few people intuitively get from 'WalMart gets $x billion in indirect subsidies' to that question on their own. Certainly took me a number of years!