4 ms·
Nobody leaked any data here. These were public profiles that were "controlled" by a robots.txt file. The judge appears to question whether robots.txt is suffi
by alistairSH 7y ago
Nobody leaked any data here. These were public profiles that were "controlled" by a robots.txt file.
The judge appears to question whether robots.txt is sufficient to prevent scraping, or if a proper authorization step would be required.
The best real-world analogy I can come up with... I post a No Trespassing sign on my garden, but don't fence/gate the property. Is it ok to access the property and take my tomatoes? After all, the sign is just a suggestion... had I really wanted to prevent access, I'd install a fence.
- sgc 7y agoIt's more like a store putting up a no shoes no shirt no service sign and then trying to sue for trespass when a beachgoer comes in to shop anyway. LinkedIn is a business with publicly accessible assets they want to be frequented, but they want to control how you do that. However they are finding the laws regulating the rights people have in respect to frequenting places open to the public apply.
- JamesBarney 7y agoI think this is the best analogy I've seen on this thread.
- merb 7y agojep. it's more like having a public store and only letting some people into it. like only males, no womans. because they clearly allowed the google bot.
- mullingitover 7y agoMore like only letting humans into it, and only one type of robot, the googlebot. Then this company is ignoring the posted rules and sending armies of robots into the store to photograph every square inch of the business.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWell I'm sorry, but if I opt to wrap a cURL call in a bash for loop, I'm still a human that tries to access the same resources, only with a different user agent. There is legitimate individual interest in both scraping and non-browser HTTP sessions.
- jibal 7y agoTaking your tomatoes is theft, sign or no. That has nothing to do with this case.
- qtplatypus 7y agoWhere I live in order to be trespass it has to be an enclosed space. If you don’t fence your property then it is not tesspass.