5 ms·
International wires are a bad example because they charge a huge FOREX spread. For a high-ticket transfer, you'd need to use a brokerage for the exchange first,
by arcticbull 7y ago
International wires are a bad example because they charge a huge FOREX spread. For a high-ticket transfer, you'd need to use a brokerage for the exchange first, which is also very cheap, but a bit more than $25 ($20 per million at InteractiveBrokers). Then a very cheap domestic wire for the last mile. Or, for small-ticket transfer TransferWise is around 0.85% for the whole exchange.
- isostatic 7y agoNo they don't, if I shift $500m from a US bank (in USD) to a swiss bank (in USD) it attracts no FOREX and barely any cost.
- pavlov 7y agoInternational banks are happy to open USD denominated accounts if you're a business or a private customer with a bit more than just paychecks and bills coming and going. Then you can send and receive USD with no exchange fee. If you need to spend it locally, you still need forex at some point — but that's a much more predictable proposition than going from the wildly volatile BTC to local currency.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoHow is that comparable at all? The original transaction is BTC->BTC. Why are you comparing to a currency exchange?
- arcticbull 7y agoFair point!
- mikepurvis 7y agoDepending on the regions, you can do tricks with your investment account too— Norbert's Gambit is the famous one for cheaply moving a lot of money between USD and CAD: https://medium.com/young-wild-and-cheap/the-norberts-gambit-trick-to-exchange-usd-and-cad-for-dummies-d47d7e2a5d8f https://medium.com/young-wild-and-cheap/the-norberts-gambit-...
- derriz 7y agoIs Norbert's Gambit anything but theoretical? It sounds like a guaranteed way to lose money. Given the tick size, crossing the spread with this ETF is going to cost you around 10bp alone. Never mind that this ETF only holds $45m in assets - you're only going to be able to get a very small amount without eating through price levels. On top of all this you have to carry 3 days of currency risk? I'm sure other online discount brokers are similar, but I checked Interactive Brokers, since I'm a customer, and they charge max 0.2bp fees, the spreads are around 1bp and there's no currency risk.
- chrisfosterelli 7y agoAre you in the US? While I've never personally done Norbert's Gambit my understanding is that it's extremely popular for Canadian investors to do if they want to get USD. Might not be vice-versa. The most common use case I'm familiar with is within RRSPs, as there is sometimes a tax advantage to using US-listed ETFs within them. Most brokerages charge 1.5-2% to do currency conversion so it would be a lot better deal to do Norbert's Gambit to get USD trading funds.
- eru 7y agoThat's weird? Why is paying the ETF spread twice cheaper than paying the CAD/USD spread once?
- perl4ever 7y agoFor some reason, people think the cost of buying and selling a security is equal to the explicit commissions and fees, I guess.
- eru 7y agoGiven some weird structure of fees and spread, paying the ETF spread twice might very well be cheaper. I have no clue. I was just wondering, what weirdness must be going on to make that so.
- dclusin 7y agoYou'd probably be best served to just go through an investment bank. FX market is relationship driven unlike the stock market. You don't have any of the trading relationships with the huge players in the market, and probably never will. The cost in time and money to participate in these markets vastly outweighs the paltry sum the traders are making on your transaction. Solicit quotes from multiple counterparties, pay attention to the institutional rates, and make sure you aren't getting screwed too badly.
- rolltiide 7y agookay then. domestic wire transfer. we done yet?