4 ms·

Is the leaf structure in anyway necessary for the chemical reactions or is it just a nice, familiar form that makes the project seem more natural than some arra

• Qwertystop 7y ago
  From the article and video, looks like the requirements are a thin tube and a block of translucent material to focus light onto the tube. And presumably the tube needs to be the right length, to give it enough sun time to react at a given flow speed. I would guess that while the leaf shape in particular is not required, the loose space-filling curve is a good shape for the tube to get the most use out of the block. Could it perhaps be slightly more space-efficient with a rectangle and a heater-coil shape? Maybe, but I'd expect not by much, and I would expect other resource constraints (the reactants) to matter before you've filled all available sunny spots and need to maximize medicine-per-square-meter, if only because sunny rooftops are not exactly high-demand space.
  • dpflan 7y ago
    I saw the leaves, read the article, then thought the leaf structure was a mere contrivance that wasn't necessary and perhaps made scaling manufacturing actually a bit harder/expensive than simpler geometries (neither chem nor manufacturing are domains I claim to understand, so someone more knowledgeable may have real insights).
  • tripletmass 7y ago
    The change from silicone to rigid stuff also smacks of way better insect resilience in the field. (n.b. photochemistry to work under 3 bar as to keep plastic from creeping into leaky balloon form.)