4 ms·
The stratifications on this are troubling. > But there are wide differences in assessments by partisanship. Nine in 10 Democrats think weather disasters are mo
by westurner 7y ago
The stratifications on this are troubling.
> But there are wide differences in assessments by partisanship. Nine in 10 Democrats think weather disasters are more extreme, compared with about half of Republicans.
It's not a partisan issue: we all pay these costs.
> Majorities of adults across demographic groups think weather disasters are getting more severe, according to the poll. College-educated Americans are slightly more likely than those without a degree to say so, 79 percent versus 69 percent.
Weather disasters are getting more severe. It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe.
- jvagner 7y agoBeen spending the better part of this week with the "Yeah, but sh*t happens.." relatives. They don't deny what you say, but it doesn't seem plausible that we will do anything about it, so why worry? and why are you worked up? These are the same relatives whose house was destroyed by Sandy and they're still waiting on paperwork and final checks so they can own the rebuild free and clear.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThere's no reason to worry when you have enough clout to get a check. It's not the jerks with beach-front cottages that get flooded that are gonna get screwed here, it's the people who's trailers are blown away who will be screwed. When you have a safety net (in this case that safety net it enough combined clout to convince the government to bail you out) you have much less incentive to do anything about the problem.
- magduf 7y ago>it's the people who's trailers are blown away who will be screwed I don't really see the problem here. They're the ones voting for the leadership that denies climate change, they're the ones watching Fox News, they're the ones who go to churches where their pastors tell them that God loves rich people more and that climate change is a hoax. They're also the ones who refuse to give up their guns and vote for anyone who sides that way, and they're the ones who insist on driving huge, gas-guzzling vehicles everywhere (and then complaining about gas prices) instead of living in town, and want the rest of the country to finance their unsustainable rural lifestyle. I have no sympathy.
- vorpalhex 7y agoYou understand that a political characterization is just that, right? Actual human belief is nuanced. Just as all democrats are not green-deal loving firearm ownership rejecting hippies, not all republicans are church going fox news watching SUV drivers.
- magduf 7y agoI realize that, but the Republican voters are much more similar to each other (though it varies a lot by region) than the Democrat voters are to each other. Basically, conservatives are people who want to preserve the status quo (or perhaps go backwards to some halcyon time), and liberals are people who want a change to the status quo. This means that liberals are necessarily going to have different ideas about which direction they want to take, while conservatives are starting at the same place so they're necessarily going to agree more with each other. And from my decades of experience of having family in the South, yes, most of them really are church-going Fox News watching pickup truck drivers (the SUV drivers are more the suburbanites; we were talking about trailer park dwellers here).
- BurningCycles 7y ago>Basically, conservatives are people who want to preserve the status quo (or perhaps go backwards to some halcyon time), and liberals are people who want a change to the status quo. I believe you are confusing liberals with progressives. As for Fox News, as biased as they are, CBS, MSNBC and CNN are right up there with them. Mainstream media is a sad circus these days, not a single of the outlets are even remotely interested in facts or even a hint of objectivity, it's all about attacking 'the other side' by any means.
- nindalf 7y ago> Republican voters are much more similar to each other Wow. Never saw a more perfect example of someone believing in Out-group Homogeneity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Out-group_homogeneity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Out-group_homogeneity)
- 7y ago
- munificent 7y ago> it's the people who's trailers are blown away who will be screwed It's more people in developing countries that are going to get screwed. Sucks for poor people in the US too (in part because the US is becoming more like a third-world country as economic disparity and corruption increase), but it's going to be devastating to coastal third-world countries like Bangladesh. My tin-foil hat theory lately is that the reason we are seeing a rise in fascism, nationalism, and closed borders lately is because those in power see a great tide of climate refuges coming in the future and don't want it to be their problem. They are treating the Earth like a zero sum game where if millions are to die, all that matters is that it isn't their country's millions.
- DuskStar 7y agoIf you believe that the coordination problem required to prevent global climate change is intractable (how are we going to make Russia stop burning oil? Nigeria? Pakistan?), then taking steps to ensure that your country comes out of that alive makes sense. Or at least makes sense if you value people in the relatively standard human order (self ~ close family > far family > community > region > country > everyone else) - some people might have different steps in there, but it's almost always going to end with members of some in group being worth more than people not in that group. And if you say "but I'm not like that! I care about everyone equally!", then that's nice, but I don't believe you. (unless you're the kind of person who gives a large portion of their income to 3rd world charities - and I mean 50%+ there. Otherwise, aren't you demonstrating that you care about yourself more than random 3rd world children you've never met?)
- TrainedMonkey 7y ago> Weather disasters are getting more severe. It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe. There is also more infrastructure for weather disasters to destroy. A perhaps more interesting metric would be an average extreme weather impact per person.
- pixl97 7y agoOne huge problem with infrastructure is people are building it where it shouldn't be without climate change. We just love building in flood zones in the US. We love making more and bigger food zones with suburban expansion. Then as the climate gets worse the problems get worse at a much faster rate than one would expect.
- glogla 7y agoHumans need water, and civilisation needs a lot of it. 90 % of cities are built in flood plain because until relatively recently (~200 years or something?) it was impossible to have a city outside of flood plain. Now, we don't need to do it that way, but it still makes things more expensive.
- fromthestart 7y ago> It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe. There is no data to support such an assertion. It's confirmation bias stemming from the belief that climate change will lead to such an effect.
- westurner 7y ago> "2017: Climate Science Special Report: Fourth National Climate Assessment, Volume I" > "Chapter 9: Extreme Storms" lists a number of relevant Key Findings with supporting evidence (citations) and degrees of confidence: https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/
- mistermann 7y ago> The stratifications on this are troubling. They are, yet almost no one I know of (in leadership positions, or the general public) seems to think they're troubling enough to put any serious effort into determining with some level of certainty why there is so much stratification along political lines on so many important issues, this being only one of them. "Conservatives are uneducated" sounds about right so that's what we'll go with it seems, regardless of whether it's actually correct. That belief may be right, but it may not. > It's not a partisan issue: we all pay these costs. In one perspective, but as is usually the case, there are several perspectives involved. Another non-trivial perspective is that the solution requires non-partisan cooperation, and from that perspective partisanship is not only an issue, it is a crucially important issue, so we might be well served by putting some effort into understanding the true nature of it. > Weather disasters are getting more severe. It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe. For certain definitions of "more", "severe", "objectively", "true", and "frequent". So if the problem isn't simply that "conservatives are uneducated", what else might it be? I think the answer lies in the incredibly complex manner in which people perceive the world in general, what information they consume, how they perceive that information, and how they integrate it into their personal internal overall worldview. People think they think in facts, but they actually think in stories, and in turn this affects how they consume new information. Take this simple article as an example, and notice the variety of perspectives we see already with just a few (14 at the time of my writing) comments posted in this thread. Notice how people aren't discussing just the content of the article, but rather including related ideas from past information they have consumed and stored (the mechanics of which we do not understand) within the mental model of the world they hold in their brain. An even better example of this behavior can be seen in the recent discussion on the CDC report on vaping: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20915520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20915520 Observe all the complex perspectives based on the very same "facts" in the article. Observe all the assertions of related "facts", that are actually only opinions. Observe all the mind reading. If you start looking for this phenomenon you will notice it everywhere, and if you pay closer attention you may also notice that certain topics are particularly prone to devolving into narrative (rather than fact) based conversation. The usual suspects are obvious: religion, gender, sexuality, etc, but smoking/vaping seems to me like somewhat of an interesting outlier. The former examples are very closely tied to personal identity, but while smoking/vaping shares an identity attribute to some degree, I feel like there's some other unseen psychological issue in play that results in such high polarization of beliefs. My guess is you and I see very different things despite consuming the very same article. I lean conservative/libertarian (generally speaking), and I am deeply distrustful of government (for extremely good reasons I believe), so I know for a fact that my interpretation of the article is going to be heavily distorted by that. Any logical inconsistency, ambiguousness, disingenuousness, technical dishonesty, or anything else along those lines is going to get red flagged in my mind, whereas others will read it in a much more forgiving fashion. And in an article on a different political hot topic, we will switch our behaviors. In such threads, I think it would be extremely interesting for people with opposing views to post excerpts of the parts that "catch your attention", with an explanation of why. This is kind of what happens anyway, but I'm thinking with a completely different motive: rather than quoting excerpts with commentary to argue your ~political side of the issue with the goal of "winning the argument", take an unemotional, more abstract view of your personal cognitive processing of the article, and post commentary on ~why/how you believe you feel you consider that important on a psychological level. Psychological self-analysis is famously difficult, but even with moderate success I suspect some very interesting things would rise to the surface.
- jeffdavis 7y ago> Weather disasters are getting more severe. It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe. Source? What definitions are being used for severity? How is the sample of events selected? Is there a statistically-significant effect or might it be random variation?
- westurner 7y ago> Source? What definitions are being used for severity? How is the sample of events selected? Is there a statistically-significant effect or might it be random variation? These are great questions that any good skeptic / data scientist should always be asking. Here are some summary opinions based upon meta analyses with varyingly stringent inclusion criteria. ( I had hoped that the other top-level post I posted here would develop into a discussion, but these excerpts seem to have bubbled up. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20919368 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20919368 ) "Scientific consensus on climate change" lists concurring, non-commital, and opposing groups of persons with and without conflicting interests: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_consensus_on_climate_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_consensus_on_climat... USGCRP, "2017: Climate Science Special Report: Fourth National Climate Assessment, Volume I" [Wuebbles, D.J., D.W. Fahey, K.A. Hibbard, D.J. Dokken, B.C. Stewart, and T.K. Maycock (eds.)]. U.S. Global Change Research Program, Washington, DC, USA, 470 pp, doi: 10.7930/J0J964J6. "Chapter 8: Droughts, Floods, and Wildfire" https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/8/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/8/ "Chapter 9: Extreme Storms" https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/ "Appendix A: Observational Datasets Used in Climate Studies" https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/appendix-a/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/appendix-a/ The key findings in this report do list supporting evidence and degrees of confidence in predictions about the frequency and severity of severe weather events. I'll now proceed to support the challenged claim that disaster severity and frequency are increasing by citing disaster relief cost charts which do not directly support the claim. Unlike your typical televised debate or congressional session, I have: visual aids, a computer, linked to the sources I've referenced. Finding the datasets ( https://schema.org/Dataset https://schema.org/Dataset ) for these charts may be something that someone has time for while the costs to taxpayers and insurance holders are certainly increasing for a number of reasons. "Taxpayer spending on U.S. disaster fund explodes amid climate change, population trends" (2019) has a nice chart displaying "Disaster-relief appropriations, 10-year rolling median" https://www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2019/04/22/taxpayer-spending-us-disaster-fund-explodes-amid-climate-change-population-trends/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2019/04/22/taxpayer... "2018's Billion Dollar Disasters in Context" includes a chart from NOAA: "Billion-Dollar Disaster Event Types by Year (CPI-Adjusted)" with the title embedded in the image text - which I searched for - and eventually found the source of: [1] https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/beyond-data/2018s-billion-dollar-disasters-context https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/beyond-data/2018... [1] "Billion-Dollar Weather and Climate Disasters: Time Series" (1980-2019) https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/time-series https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/time-series
- commandlinefan 7y ago> we all pay these costs ... if there actually are costs to pay. You seem to be sidestepping the actual question here.
- westurner 7y ago"Billion-Dollar Weather and Climate Disasters: Time Series" (1980-2019) https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/time-series https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/time-series
- lloyddobbler 7y ago> It is objectively, quantitatively true that weather disasters are getting more frequent and more severe. From the article, storms may be getting slightly more severe - but "more frequent" is incorrect: > Scientific studies indicate a warming world has slightly stronger hurricanes, but they don’t show an increase in the number storms hitting land, Colorado State University hurricane researcher Phil Klotzbach said. He said the real climate change effect causing more damage is storm surge from rising seas, wetter storms dumping more rain and more people living in vulnerable areas. Now, we all should do what we can to address it - but we all should also examine whether we're picking and choosing only scientific observations that support our feelings/pre-conceived notions while discarding the rest of the data.
- westurner 7y agoThe article seems to have focused on perceptions of persons who aren't concerned with taking an evidence-based look (at various types of storms: floods, cyclones (i.e. hurricanes), severe thunderstorms, windstorms. Regardless, costs are increasing. I've listed a few sources here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20925127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20925127 "2017: Climate Science Special Report: Fourth National Climate Assessment, Volume I" > "Chapter 9: Extreme Storms" lists a number of relevant Key Findings with supporting evidence (citations) and degrees of confidence: https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/