6 ms·
I'm not saying this isn't a problem, but it seems pretty minor compared to the fact that: 1) Apple's apps come preinstalled on every iPhone. 2) Apple's apps h
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I'm not saying this isn't a problem, but it seems pretty minor compared to the fact that:
1) Apple's apps come preinstalled on every iPhone.
2) Apple's apps have permission to do things that 3rd party apps cannot.
If I search for "Web Browser" on the App Store... well, technically I'll get results from third parties, but every single one is just a UI skin around Apple's own browser. That strikes me as a much larger problem.
- frogpelt 7y agoI see it differently. Since Apple makes the hardware and the software I don't have a problem with them preinstalling their own products. However, when a user is clearly searching for alternatives on the app store, it matters how far down you have to scroll to find a 3rd party app. Spotify being the 23rd result for a "music" search is absurd.
- panpanna 7y ago> Spotify being the 23rd result for a "music" search is absurd I have hard time believing this was not intentional. Edit: on Android Spotify is at place 2-4. iTunes is nowhere to be seen but that could be explained with the horrible reviews it has received (some are even legit).
- mitchty 7y agoI have a hard time believing it was. iTunes search is wicked bad and has been since day 1. After they started allowing tags for apps it got worse, which is an impressive achievement.
- panpanna 7y agoNote how this doesn't affect apples own apps?
- yoz-y 7y agoJudging from the sheer number of "ASO" companies that contacted me the week I put out an app on the store, I believe that the main problem is mainly really bad spam control.
- saagarjha 7y agoYeah, companies frequently put their competitors' names in their keywords. Not going to name any names, but it's particularly bad in the ride sharing industry.
- Fnoord 7y agoPlay Store search is also (still) notoriously bad. Even if it is a 1:1 hit, it does not show that as first entry. And it is full with malware.
- tombrossman 7y agoThe advantage to using Google Play is that apps containing ads are clearly labelled as such. Apple won't tell you this in advance. (This was my biggest surprise, recently switching from Android after the CopperheadOS meltdown)
- Fnoord 7y agoHonestly I care less about ads and more about trackers. Google Play says nada about trackers. Exodus project (and therefore F-Droid) does. If you come from CopperheadOS I can recommend /e/ or LineageOS + microG (/e/ also contains microG). microG does not implement GAds. You will still need to block trackers though.
- ajscanlan 7y agoDoes the iOS App Store mention if an app uses trackers?
- saagarjha 7y agoNope. I would expect it to be difficult to analyze for that, at least with the amount of effort Apple is currently putting into App Store review.
- tombrossman 7y agoI agree with you about the trackers, but I just assume ads=tracking. I cannot see any app marketplace saying their apps contain tracking in the main description (it's always buried in the fine print). My understanding is that GrapheneOS[0] is the successor to CopperheadOS, and I think that's what I'll try next. There isn't an Exodus Privacy or F-Droid for iOS and these are sorely missed. [0]https://grapheneos.org/ https://grapheneos.org/
- lern_too_spel 7y agoHow can you put iMovie above Spotify in a search results for "music" without putting your thumb on the ranker?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- noer 7y ago>Spotify being the 23rd result for a "music" search is absurd. That search term is so broad it's difficult to figure out exactly what the users intent is for that. Do they want to listen to music? Do they want to create or record music? FWIW, I just searched for "music" and saw: An ad, a story ("run with music"), apple music, two music players I've never heard of and finally Spotify in position 6.
- xenihn 7y ago>That search term is so broad it's difficult to figure out exactly what the users intent is for that. Search optimization. Determine what most users ultimately end up selecting for specific queries, build up your data set over time, then weigh priorities and determine result order based on that.
- the_other 7y ago... which might explain why Spotify ranks lower than the expectation here. Perhaps more people search for "spotify" when they want Spotify.
- mthoms 7y ago>That search term is so broad it's difficult to figure out exactly what the users intent is for that I disagree. It's broad in the sense that that the user could be searching for any number of things. It's not broad in the sense that the user is likely looking for a music listening app. Think of the real world equivalent. In common conversation when someone says "I like music", do you presume that they enjoy listening to, or making, music? I'd say the intent is pretty clear for the majority of users.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> However, when a user is clearly searching for alternatives on the app store, it matters how far down you have to scroll to find a 3rd party app. If I delete Apple's Calendar, install a third party Calendar app (like Fantastical), and click a date link, I'll get a message asking me if I want to reinstall Apple's Calendar. I think it's pretty darn clear in that scenario what the user actually wants.
- umvi 7y agoOn the other hand, Apple products are (or were) frequently marketed towards the tech illiterate ("it just works") and so it's possible grandma accidentally deleted the calendar, tried to re-download via the App Store, downloaded the wrong one, etc.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoGmail on iOS will open Google Chrome if you have it installed. I don't know how they do it, but they definitely are doing it.
- penagwin 7y agoI believe the app itself (Gmail) is requesting to use Chrome. So each individual app would need to request Chrome, something I'm sure Google's apps can do, but [insert random app here] won't.
- benologist 7y agoI see it differently. Way back when Microsoft shipped Internet Explorer with Windows it ruined companies. We see companies being arbitrarily ruined by Apple's actions every month. This platform abuse triggered massive antitrust actions in the US and EU that Microsoft lost quite spectacularly, costing them a fortune and forcing many changes to their software. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browser_wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browser_wars
- esmi 7y agoActually, in the US, Microsoft lost, won the appeal, then settled. Notice this key quote from below, "However, the DOJ did not require Microsoft to change any of its code nor prevent Microsoft from tying other software with Windows in the future." Not really a loss I would say. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
- snowwrestler 7y agoMicrosoft shipping IE in Windows did not ruin companies. What ruined companies (and what MS was actually prosecuted for) was Microsoft telling PC manufacturers "we will only sell you Windows OS if you agree to NOT install any other browsers on your computers." Those agreements were how MS abused their OS monopoly to wrongfully exclude other browsers from the market. Up to that point, Netscape was selling their browser direct to Dell, HP, Gateway, etc. to be preloaded on machines they sold. Microsoft was a supplier to PC companies and the market they distorted was the software supplier market. Apple themselves are the device manufacturer and have under 50% share in that market; it's not a comparable situation.
- benologist 7y agoThe similarity is ruining companies via abuse of their platform position, which doesn't depend on market share or monopoly or replicating Microsoft's particular malfeasance.
- ferdbold 7y agoSpotify was the 2nd result under Apple Music when I searched myself, though I have both installed so it probably came down to that
- rstupek 7y agoSpotify was 4th for me searching for "music" and I do not have it installed
- LaMarseillaise 7y agoI performed this search and Spotify is the 4th result, following Apple Music and two nearly exact matches (and not counting the ad). Also, the name is too long.
- Betelgeuse90 7y agoSpotify is 7th place for me. Apple Music is first. Maybe the country you're in makes a difference.
- frogpelt 7y agoSpotify 23rd was a reference to the article in the NY Times. It's 5th for me today, not including the Pandora ad at the top. Quote from the infographic in the article: "Before Apple Music arrived in the App Store, Spotify was for years the first result in searches for “music.” Shortly after Apple Music was added to the store in June 2016, it took the top spot. By then, Spotify had fallen to fourth place. In Feb. 2018, Apple apps suddenly appeared in the top six results for “music.” By the end of 2018, there were eight, some of which were unrelated to music. At this point, Spotify was the 23rd result. Spotify complained to European regulators in March that Apple was abusing its role as the gatekeeper of the App Store. By April, all but two of Apple’s apps disappeared from the top results for “music.”"
- wodenokoto 7y agoIt's 4th for me, after something called "Playtune" that has a logo that's a ripoff of Youtube, and is placed in the "Photo and Video" category instead of the "Music" category. That still feels like Apple is penalising Spotify ...
- fitzroy 7y agoFor me, Spotify is the 4th app when searching for "music", but it's the first app that doesn't contain the word "music" as the first or second word in the name. It goes: 1. Apple Music 2. Music 3. Music> 4. Spotify New music and podcasts
- bluedino 7y agoIf I search Google for 'music', Spotify dooesn't come up on the first page either. YouTube - Music Channel music.youtube.com play.google.com/music play.google.com/store/music Music - Wikipedia MusicChoice.com Youtube Music on the App Store Mtv.com
- kalleboo 7y agoI don't even get Spotify on the second page of results - but I do get articles from The Verge and TechCrunch about Spotify. Spotify itself shows up on the third page. For me Google even has a "Related search: Music platforms" box that contains YouTube, Google Play, SoundCloud, iTunes and TIDAL (no Spotify)
- makomk 7y agoAccording to the article, Apple quietly changed the ranking of Spotify after they complained to European antitrust regulators about it.
- jbverschoor 7y agoI think spotify used it's 100characters for keywords mainly for typos. If I search for "Music" on google (incognito, google.com), spotify is nr 16 (page 2).
- lewisgodowski 7y agoYMMV, I searched "music" and Spotify is the 4th result.
- riantogo 7y agoI feel you should be okay with that. It is just an extension of what you have accepted: Apple makes the hardware, software… and owns/controls the App Store.
- saagarjha 7y agoFYI, on my phone these are the results for "Music", in order: * Search ad for Spotify. * App Store story for "Run With Music". * Apple Music. * Some app called "Music". * Some app called "Music>". * Spotify. * YouTube Music. * SoundCloud.
- thebigspacefuck 7y agoWhen I was new to iOS, I wasn't always looking for alternatives. Sometimes finding out an app was already on my phone related to what I was searching for was genuinely helpful. I didn't realize that "Books" could play Audiobooks, for example. It didn't end up being the best app for me, but it was useful to see Books as a search result so I knew that it could do something I was looking for another app to do.
- bluntfang 7y ago>Apple's apps come preinstalled on every iPhone. Not only that, but the autocreated links to addresses in the messaging app will not work with other map apps. In fact, if you've uninstalled the apple maps app, the address links in messenger are completely useless. * unless i'm mistaken, but I'm a fairly adept technical user and haven't found a way to make address links work.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoYou're not mistaken. I'd classify that under "3rd party apps have permission to do things other apps cannot." Yet another example would be how Apple Pay comes up automatically near payment terminals. Or how most of the default actions in the Share Sheet—all of which are for Apple Apps—cannot be turned off.
- coldtea 7y ago>Apple's apps come preinstalled on every iPhone. Whose apps should have come preinstalled on iPhones? Samsungs? No apps, let the user install everything from scratch? The whole value proposition from Apple is that you get something that "Just works". It might have issues and bugs, like everything has, but the idea behind "just works" => is more or less ready, no fiddling required for the regular Joe.
- panpanna 7y ago> Whose apps should have come preinstalled on iPhones? At Redmond, we believe everyones apps should come pre-installed. Bought a PC for serious work? well f--- you and please enjoy some candy crush!
- iamzozo 7y agoI never forget the IE war, when everybody complain about the preinstalled browser. And that time they called "monopolistic practices". At apple, they even don't know what these words mean... /s
- coldtea 7y ago>I never forget the IE war, when everybody complain about the preinstalled browser. And that time they called "monopolistic practices" That's because at that time Microsoft had a monopoly. >At apple, they even don't know what these words mean... /s That's because Apple never had a monopoly. Their market share was always on the low 10% (desktop), or the mid-40s (mobile).
- hellomyguys 7y agoDid you read the article? If you search for Podcast not only is Apple’s podcast app is first, but so it is follows by their compass app, find my friends, their tips app, their tv app, their watch app, their files app, their iTunes app, Apple Books, their reminders app, their news app, their contacts app, then their voice memos app before any 3rd party podcasts app appears. Meta comment regarding HN community... looking at the comments here it seems like most people didn’t read the article, and just assumed what is being reported.
- grzm 7y agoRegarding the HN community, the guidelines are pretty specific on the topic of your comment: > Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gamblor956 7y agoIn this case his comment is appropriate, because the comments here on HN clearly indicate that the commenters had not read the article.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoIf a strong conviction that others haven't read the article could supersede the guideline, the guideline would be quite useless. Anyone who comments "Did you even read the article?" presumably believes that the parent has not read the article. (Just for what it's worth, I did read the article in full before commenting, and I don't think the paraphrased portion changes what I wrote.)
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoSo what? That’s a stupid guideline. A better one would be: Please don’t comment on whether someone’s comment follows some guidelines.
- grezql 7y agofor half a year ago when i searched for "Spotify" in the norwegian appstore the first result was some kind of rip-off app with tons of complaints by users thinking it was the official app. Spotify the real app was number 2. Apple is abusing its market position, it has been obvious for me long before this article and the lawsuits. But coming from a country not a member of EU or strong enough on its own, its hard to do anything about it.
- alienreborn 7y agoYou don't see a problem with that first scenario where search results for 'podcasts' is filled with completely unrelated apps from Apple?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI do see a problem. However, if I were Spotify, I wouldn't be too concerned about this particular problem. Apple Music and Apple Podcasts come preinstalled on every iPhone, so Spotify effectively lost the discoverability battle before the user even got to the App Store. By contrast, I'd be quite concerned that Apple is outright preventing me from making my app as good as their first party offerings. Spotify will not ever be able to open Podcast links shared from Safari, or fully integrate into Siri.
- wil421 7y agoI had an Android a few years ago and #2 was a big issue. AT&T installed all types of apps including an automatic WiFi connecting app. I had to flash a google image to get rid of it. I’d be driving down the road and my maps or other apps would lose connections. Turns out I was being forced to connect to AT&T stores and Starbucks at red lights (anywhere attwifi was detected). Not to mention all the Samsung bloatware.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoTwo points: 1. Granting more permissions to third party apps won't cause the iPhone to ship with Samsung bloatware. 2. I'm not necessarily advocating for 3rd party app privileges to be significantly expanded. However, Apple's own apps should mostly play by the same rules. If they can't, that's a sign the rules are too restrictive.
- kitsunesoba 7y agoNew app permissions must be added judiciously, as it’s been proven time and time again that developers can and will abuse them in whatever ways they can, including training and desensitizing users if necessary. Apple tends to open capabilities up once they’re confident they’ve been able to make them reasonably airtight against abuse. That seems like a very sensible policy to me, even if it means that certain features come at a glacial pace.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOkay, but then Apple shouldn't use them in their own apps either.
- kitsunesoba 7y agoBut then Apple is not only putting themselves at a disadvantage against other platforms for long stretches of time (“iOS can do that with Apple stuff” is better than “iOS can’t do that”), but also giving up their ability to dogfood new APIs and test them in a much larger capacity than even a public beta would allow. In order to remain competitive, they’d be forced to release half-baked/under-tested APIs, which is never good. That’s exactly how the Android developer story got as bad as it did at its lowest points.