4 ms·
Can you really blame the British who left HK 22 years ago? I mean China claims to be an actual Communist country and Communism is at least to some degree incom
by rwmj 7y ago
Can you really blame the British who left HK 22 years ago? I mean China claims to be an actual Communist country and Communism is at least to some degree incompatible with "[t]he whole economy [...] under the control of 14 rich billionaires." Even though there's the Basic Law providing a degree of separation, could the Chinese not have at least influenced the direction of inequality over 22 years?
- ddeck 7y agoI am quite surprised that the Chinese have allowed the crony capitalism that the Hong Kong Government system is based on to continue unabated. The continually rising levels of inequality that it has generated have been an obvious risk to social stability for a long time, which presumably the CCP are very keen to maintain. The government and press regularly celebrate achieving the title of "Freest economy on earth" (top place for the last 25 years). What is less frequently mentioned is that Hong Kong tops the Economist's Crony Capitalist Index, ahead of Russia in second place. [2] With respect to the British, the structure of the government (functional constituencies etc.) can certainly be traced back to them. And as highlighted this SCMP article that examines the cozy business/government relationship in light of the protests [3]: The roots of Hong Kong’s entangled ties between business and politics can be traced to the city’s colonial history, when hometown business elites were also local community leaders, endorsed and endowed by administrators with influence and leadership roles. In the city’s first post-colonial administration after 1997, businessmen made up eight of the 11 non-official members of Tung Chee-hwa’s cabinet. The ratio was little changed at 70 per cent under Tung’s successor Donald Tsang Yam-kuen, falling to half during Leung Chun-ying’s term from 2012 to 2017. [1] https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201901/25/P2019012500772.htm https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201901/25/P2019012500772... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony-capitalism_index#2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony-capitalism_index#2016 [3] https://www.scmp.com/business/article/3025260/developers-cosy-ties-politics-may-explain-hong-kongs-biggest-woe-widening https://www.scmp.com/business/article/3025260/developers-cos...
- FabHK 7y ago> I am quite surprised that the Chinese have allowed the crony capitalism that the Hong Kong Government system is based on to continue unabated. Eh? You have a similar crony capitalist system in mainland China, don't you. And the understanding in HK is that there is sort of tacit "gentlemen's agreement" between Beijing and the HK elites: Beijing doesn't interfere too much with the rich and powerful in HK and their (continued) ability to rake in money, while those rich and powerful refrain from supporting or advocating for more democracy etc. In other words, both sides are pretty interested in the continuation of the status quo.
- ddeck 7y agoYou do indeed, but the the power distribution is far from even, as many a Chinese tycoon has discovered when they've come out on the wrong side of Beijing and found themselves in prison. There are always laws that can be selectively brought to bear when required. My point is that the rich and powerful in HK are unlikely to do anything that irks Beijing. They don't need to be bribed into cooperating and will do as they are told regardless. The risk to social stability of the status quo and the liklihood of it putting a significant portion of the population on the streets protesting seems a much greater risk.
- cies 7y ago> China claims to be an actual Communist country We all know that's mere lip service. Just like all those developed countries pushing their "we are democratic" propaganda, while the lobbies (equals big biz, lines up with interests of the super rich) have MUCH more power over the decision process than the voters. Thus democracy (meaning people-rule) is racket, a puppet show to hide that it is actually the money that rules.
- mnm1 7y agoSo called communist societies are the most unequal in the world. Let's not pretend that communism is anything but an authoritarian state ran by a few people for their own profit and power. A few people own everything and everyone else owns nothing. That's been communism in every single instance it has ever manifested itself in the world. Reducing inequality is the last thing in the world communists want to do. Come to think of it, it's not that much different from the extreme capitalism practiced in the US and other places in that way but that's a different point.