6 ms·
I honestly don't believe that many will step up and take over. Many will complain, but few will do the actual work. Even if it's just security fixes, there's s
by mrweasel 7y ago
I honestly don't believe that many will step up and take over. Many will complain, but few will do the actual work.
Even if it's just security fixes, there's still the process of testing and release management, and honestly, I don't blame the core Python team for no longer wanting to do release management of both Python 2 and 3.
- leejo 7y ago> Many will complain, but few will do the actual work. That's opensource in a nutshell. If there are any big shops stuck on Python 2 then they will probably throw a resource or two at this. If there are big dists using Python 2 they will do the same.
- Teknoman117 7y agoFrom what I can tell, even Google is moving to python 3 (some of their previously python 2 only tools (like repo) have gained ‘experimental’ python 3 support) this year, so they’re probably not going to be doing the work.
- bigiain 7y ago> then they will probably throw a resource or two at this Which, I'd guess, is probably gonna be 3 or 4 orders of magnitude more money than they've ever spent supporting Python2 (or 3) devs in the 10+ years they've built their own businesses on it while they sat on their hands and ignored the project's urging to upgrade to Python3... Not a lot of sympathy from me for "big shops stuck on Python2"...
- wyldfire 7y agoCanonical or Redhat will probably sell services related to supporting Python 2 and/or porting your code to Python 3.
- richardwhiuk 7y agoUbuntu 18.04 has support for Python 2.7 til 2028 I think.
- tempay 7y agoOnly for paying customers, general support will end in 2023.
- shpx 7y agoThere's a list of some enterprise Linux distros and their default python versions and their end-of-life dates on the Wikipedia article for CPython https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CPython#Distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CPython#Distribution
- tannhaeuser 7y agoI'm no Python insider, but Google has quite a lot of projects based on Python 2, including build scripts for recently released software, so I'm guessing they could at some point maintain their own Python 2 branch (which, again, I'm guessing is much less work than porting a huge amount of script code over to 3 for no material benefit).
- lozenge 7y agoThey already have one - look in their type checker repo for patches that add certain Python 3 features (type annotations) to Python 2.
- cheez 7y agoThat's sort of hilarious... What are the incentives that prevent Google from upgrading their python 2 scripts to python 3? I guess it's more productive globally to stick with a supported version of Python 2.
- tannhaeuser 7y agoNot the one you're responding to, but there are many cases where Python is used in the role of a shell script replacement eg. build scripting and test suite automation that wouldn't benefit from migration and, in fact, would suffer from half-assed migration attempts with little or no real-world testing.
- CJefferson 7y agoThe biggest problem is having a place to organise. The Python foundation is threatening to sue anyone continuing something called Python 2, or even a similar name. Finding volunteers who are willing to get sued to work on Python will be hard.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoThe motivation for that is probably avoiding what my first thought was; who is going to be the first to offer commercial extension of Python 2 support. That would be worth a lot of money to a lot of companies.
- robocat 7y agoAlso I can think of plenty of groups that would like to be able to deploy a differently secured version 2 in their best financial interest.
- CogitoCogito 7y agoI think you're blowing it out of proportion. Call your project some other name. Say that your interpreter is compatible with Python 2 and that you provide continued support. It will probably be hard to find volunteers because most are moving/have moved to Python 3, but I don't think the threat of lawsuit will scare anyone away except those who want to infringe on PSF's trademarks and in that case...good?
- bigiain 7y agoI'm finding it difficult to understand why anybody thinks supporting Python2 should be done by volunteers? What's "in it" for the volunteer? How much "fun" does "Supporting an old language where the original developers have moved on to a newer and more interesting version of the language, but there's a bunch of complaining people who still want the old language to be supported but they aren't offering to pay for it" sound? I'd rather sit in the park reading a book or walk a dog or something. I mean, there's still people taking on COBOL contracts, because businesses consider their COBOL code to be important enough to keep maintained. But they sure as hell aren't "volunteering". They're getting paid rates that even bay area twenty-something FAANG-ers would be impressed by. If Blackrock or The Vanguard Group or equivalent decided they needed continued Python2 support because it was a critical dependency on their ETF platforms (and they'd been foolish enough to not heed the "Goddamn it, just fucking upgrade to Python3 already!" advice from the core team for about a decade), I'm sure they could whip out their chequebooks and agree to a rate that Guido himself would agree support Python2 for them. But I'd hope and expect Guido (or whoever in the core team would be suitable candidates to do this work) to hold out for genuinely life-changing numbers of zeros on those cheques. And if nobody is offering to write those cheques? Well maybe that says something about the seriousness of their complaints?
- em500 7y agoRHEL 7 depends on python 2.7 and will have security/maintenance support till June 2024. So for security updates, I guess we can just track RHEL7/CentOS7 python 2.7.
- raverbashing 7y agoCorrect Also the longer a software is around, the lower the chance of some showstopper showing up (not 0% chance though) What's most likely is that one important library in 2.7 stops talking to some upgraded system version (think OpenSSL for example) then what depends on it stops working.
- Crinus 7y agoThere is Tauthon[1] which backports Python 3 features to 2 and seems to do the "actual work". It has been around a while. It was also posted in this thread below by the current maintainer of the project but for some reason that comment was downvoted to [dead]. By reading a bit around about it, i do get the impression that the Tauthon developers face a bit of hostility from the Python community, so i'm not sure how viable it'll be in the long term. I suppose it depends on how stubborn the Tauthon developers are :-P [1] https://github.com/naftaliharris/tauthon https://github.com/naftaliharris/tauthon
- Macha 7y agoIt wasn't downvoted to dead - the author has been banned, they've copied dang's comments to their profile. (Unlike other forums, banned users can still post, but their posts require someone with showdead on to vouch for it before it can be seen).