3 ms·
The article perpetuates the fiction that Chinese characters provide more than phonetic information. Mandarin uses a syllabary, so one character represents what
by ncmncm 7y ago
The article perpetuates the fiction that Chinese characters provide more than phonetic information. Mandarin uses a syllabary, so one character represents what would be two or three phonemes, which about matches the numbers in the table at the end.
- nneonneo 7y agoSorry, what? Chinese is emphatically NOT a syllabary. Characters have meaning, two characters that are pronounced the same can have different meanings. The spoken language is syllabary-ish but wide regional dialectic variations shift different characters in different ways, which could not be the case in a true syllabary. To give you just one little example of how you are not correct: 长久 - cháng jiǔ - long time/long lasting 尝酒 - cháng jiǔ - to taste wine Japanese uses Kanji (Chinese characters) not for their phonetic value (they’ve got two whole syllabaries for that), but for their meaning.
- ncmncm 7y agoThere are lots of characters that represent the same syllable, and complicated rules about which to use for writing common words, which helps to disambiguate the very numerous hononyms. The "dialectical variations" are really different languages. Mandarin speakers are taught that only pronunciations vary, but a person transcribing Cantonese to Mandarin is doing translation to a degree comparable to Italian -> French. Politically this fact is not allowed in China, but ask anyone who is bilingual in Cantonese and Mandarin. Prepare to be surprised.
- yorwba 7y agoMandarin and Cantonese are both widespread enough to have dialects of their own. For example, Dalian Mandarin has different tones and some syllables that don't exist in Standard Mandarin: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalian_dialect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalian_dialect
- brazzy 7y ago> There are lots of characters that represent the same syllable, And also (less common, but existant) characters that represent different syllables in different contexts. A prominent example would be 觉, pronounced jué in 觉得 but jiào in 睡觉 Hanzi are logographs, not a syllabary. > and complicated rules about which to use for writing common words Maybe if you have some need to believe in the bizarre fiction that Chinese characters only provide phonetic information. In the real world, the characters have meaning and history, which simply dictates what characters to use for which word.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Hanzi are logographs, not a syllabary. This is like saying English is written with logographs, not an alphabet. Kanji are logographs and not a syllabary. Hanzi are closer to being a syllabary than they are to being logographs. The sound is the primary concept. Obviously, the characters do convey considerably more than just phonetic information. But phonetic information is the first and most important thing they carry.
- ncmncm 7y agoIt is quite remarkable how people continue to believe what their elementary teacher told them, even after years and years' experience to the contrary. In English, people believe that "Elements of Style" is full of good advice despite everything good they have ever read violating every rule on every page.
- hsivonen 7y agoThe article makes a claim about Han script information density relative to measures of length. It makes no claim about how the Han script achieves it. If you consider this from the perspective of Huffman coding, it shouldn't be surprising that the script that gets the most code space in Unicode would carry the most information per symbol on average.
- ncmncm 7y agoThe point is that if they really were logographs, and not just a complicated syllabary, you would get a lot more than the equivalent of two or three letters out of them.
- nneonneo 7y agoYour math is wrong. The Chinese (Traditional) translation consists of 2202 characters (UTF-32). The English translation consists of 8555 characters. This amounts to ~3.88 English letters per Chinese character, quite a bit more than "two or three". None of the actual syllabaries get even close to the density of Chinese. Korean, the closest comparison point (a true syllabary) clocks in at 3856 characters - a far cry from 2202.
- hsivonen 7y agoYou are arguing with something that the article did not say. The substring "logo" does not occur in the article. The article makes no claim about what the Han script encodes beyond implying that the Han script isn't alphabetic, which shouldn't be controversial.