2 ms·
"Panspermia itself is a hypothesis. Panspermia from Mars specifically is a huge stretch." I think "from Mars specifically" is something that requires evidence
by perl4ever 7y ago
"Panspermia itself is a hypothesis. Panspermia from Mars specifically is a huge stretch."
I think "from Mars specifically" is something that requires evidence to treat as likely.
However, I don't think "Earth is the unique place where life originated" should be the default assumption according to Occam's razor. Nothing nearby is anything like Earth on the surface, but it's not speculation that there were billions of years and unimaginably large amounts of volume for life to develop underground in the rest of the universe, where it's warm and sheltered from radiation. The idea that nothing happened until Earth became "Earth-like" isn't the logical default. Naming the contrary of this far-fetched claim "panspermia" doesn't make it a "thing" that needs a "basis". By analogy, I would say that a creationist claim of humanity originating with Adam and Eve is what needs evidence, not the contrary assumption, that all humans had parents.
- garmaine 7y agoWhere else? Venus' habitable period, if it existed, was quite short. It's gravity is also much higher and it is inward in the solar system. Even before it turned into the hell-hole it is now, dynamical models show that it probably sent few rocks our way. The Moon appears to have formed without the resources to sustain life as we know it. There are great candidates for life in the outer solar system (Europa, Enceladus, Titan), but ejecta from these mostly get eaten up by the giant planets. The only likely candidates for solar system origin panspermia is Mars, and maybe Ceres. Only Mars (and Earth) had the long wet period with open oceans, geothermal heat sources, plate tectonics, and sizable atmosphere. Mars isn't the only option, but the odds are way, way higher. At least for life as we know it. But the point of panspermia is that it would be life as we know it ;)
- ajmurmann 7y agoIt seems that we don't know how likely life is to develop given early Earth conditions. If that has a very low chance to happen then maybe panspermia is more likely. If it turns out to likely happen given a few million years and good conditions maybe panspermia is less likely. It seems to me we know almost nothing about the likelihood of either option, so it's hard to declare that one should be the default.