3 ms·
> Tech companies disagree with the notion that they are plundering academia. A [typical large dotcom] spokesman, for example, said the company was an enthusiast
by neilv 7y ago
> Tech companies disagree with the notion that they are plundering academia. A [typical large dotcom] spokesman, for example, said the company was an enthusiastic supporter of academic research.
On occasion, I've asked multiple professors why they don't criticize particular dotcoms or industry practices, or warn undergrads about the nasty cultures of particular companies, and they've said they need the funding from those dotcoms.
Personally, I'd love it if undergrads learned a sense of professional ethics and objective understanding of current industry before they applied for internships, and, consequently, anyone who went to one of the worst (but best-paying) ones for a summer would have greatly increased difficulty getting dates when they returned.
- lainga 7y agoI (soon to be non-undergrad) got the impression around 2016 that the admiration was wearing off of our classmates who did co-op terms at FAANG. One of our peers had done a term at a Cambridge Analytica subsidiary in town, AggregateIQ, so when the news came out, it was especially prominent in (at least) my mind. I can't comment on whether any romantic efforts were impeded or not.
- chronic839 7y ago> Personally, I'd love it if undergrads learned a sense of professional ethics and objective understanding of current industry before they applied for internships Given ethics is a fuzzy line, I'll loosely define it as, what the majority would do, or deem acceptable, _given the option_ to choose between two actions. Note that many times, people don't actually have the option to choose and are simply talking from their armchair. Now, coming to internships, those undergrads receive offers from both Facebook et al. and second tier companies like Capital One, P&G, or IBM. Nearly all of them choose Facebook and the higher pay. Hell, even Facebook knows their reputation is declining and hence offers more total compensation for to offset it, and it works! Plenty of my friends from MIT/Stanford/Berkeley grad school chose Facebook upon graduating "because they paid 300K-400K TC." And yes, this is in 2019. Same thing with working professionals. I have the option to sell my computer vision person re-identification technology to a Chinese customer or a European one. Due to the deal terms, we could only pick one. Guess what, we sold to the Chinese (and presumably government controlled) company. Unethical? Yeah probably. But who gives a shit? It's a lot of money. I'll gladly put my ethics aside and do _anything_ as long as it's legal. And I took 3 useless-ass ethics classes in undergrad. There's a saying: "Everyone has a price." And it's true as ever.
- chronic73829 7y ago> Personally, I'd love it if undergrads learned a sense of professional ethics and objective understanding of current industry before they applied for internships Even with an understanding of ethics, undergrads, new grads, professionals and startup founders _usually_ pick the "unethical" option. - Facebook knows this (in 2019) and thus offers more money to offset it. Several of my grad school friends from MIT/Stanford/Berkeley chose to work at Facebook because "they gave $300K-$400K total yearly compensation." - US-based start-ups routinely sell products, give up equity control, or sell directly to the Chinese government or investors. Many times precluding them from selling to US customers/government. My startup recently closed a $20M computer vision deal with a Chinese customer related to person re-identification. Unethical? Probably to someone, yes. The reason for all of this? Because "everyone has a price." If you believe your ethics can't be compromised, well then you haven't been offered enough money.
- jacobolus 7y ago> My startup recently closed a $20M computer vision deal with a Chinese customer related to person re-identification. Unethical? Probably to someone, yes. So... helping the Chinese government surveil and repress its ethnic minorities?
- acollins1331 7y agoYou realize the Chinese government is going to use your tech in their concentration camps and you don't care at all?