2 ms·
> He believes this stems from a common perception that there must be some kind of downside to the introduction of sustainable practices: either a reduction in p
by carapace 7y ago
> He believes this stems from a common perception that there must be some kind of downside to the introduction of sustainable practices: either a reduction in product quality, or an increase in the price of manufacturing, or both.
There's an existing body of knowledge and practice for regenerative agriculture, or even productive "food forests" that are ecologically harmonious and can supply the needs of billions (meaning we don't have to postulate mass starvation as a prerequisite of ecological food production.) (One school is called Permaculture (a portmanteau of PERMAnent agriCULTURE).)
If you're doing this right there is an increase in quality and yield and a decrease in cost.
But yeah, a lot of people don't get this.
There was a question the other day, "Does regenerative agriculture scale?"
Well, yes, of course it does, the clue is in the name.
Search on "Geoff Lawton Greening the Desert" for living examples of converting barren desert into flourishing farms. Each farm is then capable of supplying not only produce and meat but also the materials to perform the same transformation at another site. Obviously, this is exponential growth.
There is a way, we must have the will.
- hinkley 7y agoWhat I've seen bumping around this area is that the cost increase is in engagement. I don't know any conventional farmers, and I don't know anyone who has known one in thirty years, so I can't tell you what sucks up their time all day. But I've heard reports it's a second job to keep the farm solvent. In a way, restoration agriculture is asking them to double down on the farm and hope it's profitable. One of the louder voices in this space is known for compartmentalizing his operation by starting tons of LLCs that collaborate. He really enjoys that sort of thing (or it makes him feel safe) but this is a lot of responsibility on a few shoulders. I don't think the import of what he's done will be appreciated until either his kid get old enough to take over from Pops, or he files bankruptcy for one of these LLCs due to an accident or a product recall.
- carapace 7y agoMy limited experience with local Permaculture farming here in CA is that the biggest challenge is reaching markets. Growing food here is pretty easy (such climate! wow) but getting that produce into the kitchens of the city-dwellers is expensive (compared to the economies of scale for big commercial outfits.)