4 ms·
>> imo licensing should be required to purchase a drone with much stronger punishments against unlicensed operators, Until the drone police give you a ticket a
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> imo licensing should be required to purchase a drone with much stronger punishments against unlicensed operators,
Until the drone police give you a ticket and take your license away. In combination with the near-blanket bans on drone use (see above) licensing would effectively mean you can only fly a drone until someone complains.
I work in aviation. I'm the the air force and used to be a pilot. The bans on drones are ridiculously over-inclusive. Miles from any helipad? There are helipads everywhere. The better scheme is to regulate them by mass and construction. They don't need extensive steel or ceramic structures. Biuld them out of aluminum and plastic. So long hitting them is less dangerous than hitting a duck, they should be given freedom at low altitudes. Allowing drones to do what they do best may reduce the need for other manned aircraft (short-haul cargo, floatplanes and such) and make the sky a less cluttered place at altitude.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou obviously know far more about aviation than I do, but it's not hard to find helipads in urban areas where a crash would be disastrous, eg near hospitals (which are often near major infrastructure like freeways for the same reasons they have helipads). A drone maliciously aimed at a helicopter's tail rotor could conceivably cause an accident depending on the construction/trickery selected by the operator, and a helicopter crash at a hospital has the potential to be a major disaster.
- knodi123 7y ago> A drone maliciously aimed at a helicopter's tail rotor could conceivably cause an accident A gun maliciously fired at a helicopter's tail rotor could conceivably cause an accident. A laser fired maliciously into the eye of a helicopter pilot could etc etc. Do we ban any of those brought near a hospital out of fear that a malicious actor would use them in the worst possible way? A malicious actor can always find a way to cause problems. A benign but stupid actor is the one we should be regulating for, and IMO keeping your drone 50 yards away from a helicopter landing pad should be sufficient.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 7y agoYa, but someone who wants to down a helicopter with a drone isn't going to care about no-fly zones. The rules aren't meant to protect against the really evil people. They are to stop accidental collisions. Getting a drone into a tail rotor would be very tricky. If the helo is in forward flight you would need a comparably fast drone to approach from the side, without being blown off course by the main rotor downwash. I doubt it possible. It might be done with the helo in a hover, but even there there would be only seconds of vulnerability. Say you get close enough, the tail rotor is itself another massive powerful fan. This wouldn't, couldn't, happen by accident. The greater threat is pilots reacting badly to sighted drones. Fear of drones might well cause more accidents than actual collisions. >> A trainee had been practising hovering about 15m (50ft) above trees ... Seeing a quadcopter flying towards them, the instructor had taken control. But he had clipped a tree with the tail rotor, causing the helicopter to crash to the ground and tip on to its side. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42904204 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42904204
- prawn 7y agoThey are generally regulated by weight at least. I fly drones as a photographer/videographer and, for the most part, don't find the regulations too heavy handed. Worrying about distance from every single tiny airfield is the main one since, as you noted, they are everywhere (unmanned fields, helipads, etc). Applied as a hard-and-fast rule, this can be a bit much when you just want a tree-height photo of a building or similar. I was in the US recently and took my drone (https://www.instagram.com/__serio__/ https://www.instagram.com/__serio__/ ). We were often in national parks, and there are also airfields everywhere so I barely found opportunities to fly. The official FAA app is a bit hopeless and it's often unclear about whether you're good to go or not. I think that a much better app from the authorities would be a major help. The casual drone operators I know in Australia make use of the official app here to stay abreast of options.
- brokenmachine 7y ago>The casual drone operators I know in Australia make use of the official app here to stay abreast of options I'm in Australia and all the "casual drone operators" I've seen DGAF and just fly the buzzing menaces wherever they want, including in National Parks. Are you allowed to fly drones over people in Australia? Because they do that too.
- prawn 7y ago"Buzzing menaces". Are those the buzzing menaces causing roadkill on the roads into the parks? Getting permission to fly in NT national parks is quite straightforward. My flights in other parks have been organised by tourism authorities. I don't doubt there are people (I suspect the majority are international tourists) pushing the rules. One thing I think doesn't help is that the official flight check app for drone operators often doesn't factor in national parks, or maybe it's if you don't have phone coverage in an area - common for parks. You can fly within 30m of people with their permission. Not over people though I imagine that's subjective - directly over people? Roughly over people?
- brokenmachine 7y ago