4 ms·
>> The new battery tested is a Li-Ion battery cell with a next-generation “single crystal” NMC cathode and a new advanced electrolyte. If this is anything like
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> The new battery tested is a Li-Ion battery cell with a next-generation “single crystal” NMC cathode and a new advanced electrolyte.
If this is anything like growing single-crystal parts for aircraft, it won't be cheap. The real question should be whether these new battery modules will last twice as long while remaining less than twice as expensive.
>> Controlling the charge to less than 100% state-of-charge also helps push the longevity.
Um, that is cheating. Running any battery at less than capacity will extend its life. You could put two batteries in the car, run them at 50% or alternate between them, and get double the life. No prizes for that.
- zaroth 7y agoThey tested it to 100% DOD (Depth of Discharge) over 5000 cycles; https://electrek.co/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2019/09/Screen-Shot-2019-09-07-at-3.27.41-PM.jpg https://electrek.co/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2019/09/Scree...
- jbm 7y ago> Um, that is cheating. Running any battery at less than capacity will extend its life. You could put two batteries in the car, run them at 50% or alternate between them, and get double the life. No prizes for that. Don't phones already do this? (IE: 100% is not really 100%, 0% is not really 0%.) I don't see it as cheating, it's akin to the practical limit vs. the actual limit
- sandworm101 7y agoThey do, but they don't claim this as any sort of advancement of battery technology. It's batteries 101.
- zeta0134 7y agoMany laptops do it too. Lenovo even markets it as a visible (and annoying) power management feature. Most however simply handle the charge cycles behind the scenes, and adjust their definition of "100%" over time, so the user can remain blissfully unaware (and less likely to change the setting). I don't mind this really. Batteries degrade over time; that's kinda just how they work, and I'd much rather have 100% mean "my device is done charging" and 0% mean "my device can no longer run." The specifics of what voltage or charge level or whatever actually translates to those numbers is not important, and honestly the battery / laptop manufacturer probably knows the right settings for those better than I ever will, so it's fine.
- Marsymars 7y ago> Lenovo even markets it as a visible (and annoying) power management feature. I wish macOS/Windows allowed this natively. I'm travelling this week with my Macbook, but it's been docked for the past couple months at 100% charge. Would be better for the battery if I could keep it at 60% charge until I plan on travelling.
- miketery 7y ago> >> Controlling the charge to less than 100% state-of-charge also helps push the longevity. > Um, that is cheating. Running any battery at less than capacity will extend its life. You could put two batteries in the car, run them at 50% or alternate between them, and get double the life. No prizes for that. I imagine the idea is that by going to X% instead of 100% fill, you extend by more than 1/X. So at 95%, perhaps we gain 20% life instead of the expected, 1/.95 ~= 1.05 -> extra 5% life.
- manmal 7y agoExactly. And this practice is widely followed by basically every BEV car manufacturer. Most of the more recent models even have a bigger battery than specified, and charge only up to 90-95% capacity while providing the specified range.
- generatorguy 7y agoWho would have thought that microchips would become so cheap? And they are built on silicon crystals. The economies of scale for batteries for cars, phones, computers, will kick in in a way that they don’t for aerospace. Car or phone battery tech will end up in airplanes!
- deepnotderp 7y agoThe amount of silicon in a microchip is tiny. By contrast, single crystal metal alloys for modern turbo fans comprise a significant portion of their cost.
- generatorguy 7y agowell microchips are small compared to turbo fans. Turbo fans are also hollow and inflated via some crazy trade secret process which the Chinese haven't figured out yet, hence them not making their own engines. So the anode or cathode on a battery, or even a whole AA size battery cell, is more on the scale of a microchip than a turbofan blade I think. plus the battery won't have to be subject to the same QA process of x-raying to ensure there are no microscopic cracks or defects. If one cell in your battery pack isn't as good as the rest it will just be managed around instead of subjecting all the cells to insane QA.
- hwillis 7y ago> If this is anything like growing single-crystal parts for aircraft, it won't be cheap. I'm still catching up, but it won't be expensive like that. You grow single crystals by keeping them hot and cooling them very slowly in a controlled atmosphere. Turbine blades are meant to operate in the hottest conditions in any machine on earth. Accordingly, they must be cooled at extremely high temperatures. The cost of single crystal turbine blades also pales in comparison to the cost of the blades themselves. > Um, that is cheating. Running any battery at less than capacity will extend its life. You could put two batteries in the car, run them at 50% or alternate between them, and get double the life. Cycle life is often plotted as equivalent full cycles. If you get two batteries, running both at 50% DoD, you will increase the amount of lifetime full-cycle equivalents by ~10-50x, depending on the chemistry. Lowering the depth of discharge means lowering the voltage difference between the electrodes. At 4.0 V you have very few side reactions. At 4.2 V, the battery is charged. At 4.3 V (~110% charge) the battery is dangerous. At 4.6 V (~120%) the battery is plating lithium onto its anode and is about to short circuit and blow its pressure release. Fire is heavily involved. Small decreases in voltage lead to big improvements in stability.