6 ms·
Report reveals play-by-play of first U.S. grid cyberattack
- cracker_jacks 7y agoSolar energy seems like a great way to decentralize energy infrastructure, making it more robust to attack.
- badrabbit 7y agoNope,that's just the source. I can imagine overloading the battery farm or downstream distribution lines.
- cracker_jacks 7y agoI'm referring to solar as a distributed energy source. Imagine homes and buildings having their own energy sources.
- badrabbit 7y agoMakes sense then,provided each building is self sufficient with it's own batteries to account for low sun exposure (few days of rain with <8hrs daylight)
- goatinaboat 7y agoUnfortunately, they will all be controlled by a smartphone app with its backend somewhere central... That’s just how it always seems to play out these days.
- MauranKilom 7y agoUnless you value independence over reliability, the bottleneck currently is batteries and not solar panels.
- PeterisP 7y agoMost of standard solar panel installations in homes and buildings don't actually provide decentralization, as they tend to be linked to the grid in a way that they will not provide power at all if the grid is down. Enabling decentralization requires extra hardware and installation costs, so it's usually not done. Essentially you need a solution to disconnect all your house from the grid in that case for safety reasons - so that your panels/batteries don't send voltage back to the grid potentially killing the repairmen fixing the broken lines, and when the grid does come up, re-linking to its frequency safely is a bit tricky, etc. It's not very hard, but it does require some extra stuff and thus expenses.
- zaroth 7y agoThere’s absolutely an extra switch that needs to be installed, but I think it’s not so much the transfer switch requirement but two main things; 1) the battery cost, and 2) net metering. Grid tie solar with net metering gives you all the benefits of a battery (except blackout coverage) with none of the cost. In other words, you get full retail value for 100% of your solar generation no matter when it comes or how much power you happen to be using at the time (because the meter runs backward, the grid acts like an infinite perfect battery) Net metering is a nice solar subsidy while batteries where extremely expensive, but as battery costs plummet I assume net metering will also disappear. It’s not really fair for the utility after all to be paying solar customers retail rates for their generation. Without net metering you will only get paid for solar power that you happen to use while it’s being generated, or that you can store for yourself to use later. Finally, I’m not 100% sure but I would imagine a solar system with a transfer switch and no battery will just immediately overload or brownout if the grid is not there to keep the voltage steady. I would assume you need a battery to be able to serve any variance in your demand (e.g. a compressor turning on) even if your 1 minute average demand is actually running below your generation capacity. TLDR: Batteries need to be cheap and net metering needs to die before you see most solar deployments that can run off grid. The good news — if batteries are durable then a battery backed grid tied system can actually pay for the batteries and then some, if you can arbitrage the demand pricing curve. This is a win-win for everyone (including utilities) and IMO absolutely the future we’re heading towards.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThey still will likely connect to the internet in some form, and sets will have the same attack vulnerabilities that can have passive bot-nets that turn on when needed.
- yourad_io 7y agoRecap: An attacker exploited a vulnerability on their firewall that allowed unauthenticated users to reboot. Exploit was public, firewall was unpatched. Unlikely that the attack was targeted, making "cyber-attack" somewhat of a stretch in my book.
- badrabbit 7y agoS/Unlikely/unknown
- arcticfox 7y agos/unknown/unlikely, according to the expert quoted in the piece. > "So far, I don't see any evidence that this was really targeted," said Reid Wightman, senior vulnerability analyst at industrial cybersecurity firm Dragos Inc. "This was probably just an automated bot that was scanning the internet for vulnerable devices, or some script kiddie," he said, using a term for an unskilled hacker.
- badrabbit 7y agoLooks like they just rebooted firewalls. I wish the lessons learned bullet points explicitly stated that management interfaces should only be accessed from internal bastion hosts (jump boxes). You'd be surprised how rare the practice is. Just getting people to disable internet access is a pain -- "but it has a really good password".
- ethbro 7y agoIf the federal government wants things to change, they should form an independent red team, running exercises against private companies, and then help companies address issues (the US government leaning on a vendor gets a lot more action than Topeka Electric Coop). With fines to increase the cost of inaction. The general consensus of reports thus far has been stupid, 101-level mistakes. And guidelines and recommendations aren't going to help with people who don't read them. E.g. Staff up NCATS [1], empower them with more binding regulation, and turn them loose to conduct non-requested tests of critical infrastructure [1] https://www.us-cert.gov/resources/ncats https://www.us-cert.gov/resources/ncats
- arkadiyt 7y agoThere's a bill in congress (the "Securing Energy Infrastructure Act") that would pilot a program to move the most important control systems to use analog, manual controls. Text of bill (pdf): https://www.king.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/01-17-19%20Securing%20Energy%20Infrastructure.pdf https://www.king.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/01-17-19%20Securin... Article summary: https://www.zdnet.com/article/us-wants-to-isolate-power-grids-with-retro-technology-to-limit-cyber-attacks/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/us-wants-to-isolate-power-grid...
- bsder 7y agoOh, joy. So it can take us days to reboot a grid blackout instead of minutes. And analog is generally slower on the other end as well. So, if I can create a fast traveling disturbance, I can destroy your equipment before the analog system kicks in. The problem isn't digital vs analog--it's connecting !@#$ to the Internet that doesn't belong on it.
- the_seraphim 7y agoIIRC the recent UK blackout was blamed on there being another 4,000 MW available to help stop the blackout, but it was a lack of automated control that prevented it coming online. Their recommendation was more automation
- kylek 7y agoShould've called it the Galactica Act
- spsful 7y agoIs anyone else having trouble reading this article? It seems to repeat itself over and over again. Reminds me of this SNL skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQG7PaOE1Mo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQG7PaOE1Mo
- gforst 7y agoThese attacks seem to be happening more and more (or reporting them more). The DOE is funding potential solutions, saw this earlier this week https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-energy-department-funds-trial-130021787.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-energy-department-funds-tr...