3 ms·
The part they don't discuss in the article is the cost. Sunlight is free, but you must pay for the electricity if you use LEDs. Water is cheap where most farms
by gus_massa 7y ago
The part they don't discuss in the article is the cost. Sunlight is free, but you must pay for the electricity if you use LEDs. Water is cheap where most farms are. So this can't be used to produce potatoes or corns or other plant with a very low price.
- bshipp 7y agoYou're absolutely correct. There are very few situations where the benefit of only using artificial light outweighs the cost of ignoring free sunlight. Most hydroponics will transition with supplemental lighting, not exclusive LED lighting. EDIT:not only does sunlight provide energy for photosynthesis but it also provides free heat for the growing facility, and in many locations heat is not an insignificant expense. Even the choice of lighting (i.e. sodium vs LED) impacts the need for supplemental heating and/or cooling as traditional highouput bulbs are very hot, whereas LED is cool. In winter, that lack of heat must be augmented by supplementary sources. But, on the flip side, LEDs permit closer placement to the plants, offering additional lighting regime options and don't add to the temperature when the facility gets too hot.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoLots of work going on with Quantum/Nano dots in greenhouse tech. Mostly with cannabis production because it’s the only crop that will justify the costs involved.
- kragen 7y agoI agree—even though solar electricity prices are falling fast, they aren't going to beat a greenhouse; I explored the question in more quantitative detail yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20905366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20905366 Obviously the issue is most pressing for sun-loving crops like corn, but I think it applies even to leaf crops like lettuce.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoNot everything can be grown indoors. But most can be grown inside..covered cropping is a good compromise between row cropping and indoor hydroponics/vertical Ag. In fact, better returns and productivity than either of those ..capital costs are higher but easy to recover.
- kragen 7y agoAre the obstacles to indoor growing just a matter of energy requirements, or is there something else I don't know about?
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoSupply chain would be a big issue. Current system is optimized for field Ag and built in losses due to food wastage.