3 ms·
IMO, I have heard no explanation that is more consistent and coherent than this. --- Consider the famous Schroedinger's Cat. The decayed particle has two sta
by paulddraper 7y ago
IMO, I have heard no explanation that is more consistent and coherent than this.
---
Consider the famous Schroedinger's Cat.
The decayed particle has two states: decayed and not decayed.
The cat has two states: dead and alive.
The researcher that opens the box has two states: sad and happy.
The waveform does not collaprse. The particle, the cat, and the researcher each have a uncollapsed waveform; i.e. are in both states.
However, these waveforms are not independent; they are entangled. The decayed particle is coincident with the dead cat and the unhappy researcher. And the undecayed particle with the alive cat and the happy researcher.
All states "exist" simultaneously, but not independently. This bifurcation in the wave function magnitudes is a "split" in the universe: every future waveform interaction will be in the context of decayed particle/dead cat/unhappy researcher and undecayed particle/alive cat/happy researcher.
"Many worlds" sounds nonsensical, but it is really just a colloquial expression for waveform entanglement.
---
Now this does present a philosophical question on how consciousness functions in light of the split waveforms.
I maintain that science -- quantum mechanics or otherwise -- has no explanation or even language to express "consciousness". It's like asking science an ethics question. And this inability applies to all science, not just quantum mechanics.
- RyanAF7 7y agoSchroedinger's Cat is the most cited and incorrectly applied outcome in all of science. There is no state, there are no changes, there is no other world. Once again, the modalities overtake concepts. Analogeous to pi. Just because the maths game of ratios creates irrationality doesn't mean we can't draw circles. It's all one. No other number, no other outcome. Maths are just puzzles.
- millstone 7y agoMany Worlds is not "a colloquial expression for wavefunction entanglement." Entangled states are part of the mathematics of QM, not a feature of an individual interpretation. MWI distinguishes itself by omitting (as you say) any notion of "collapse" from its axioms. This is appealing for simplicity but the problem is how it connects to experimental results: 1. How does the Born rule arise? If the universe split into two but the measure of cat-dead is 1/pi, why do I find myself in the cat-alive universe more often? 2. More generally, how does randomness arise? MWI contains only deterministic axioms, so how can it explain the experimental observation that measurements of similarly prepared states result in different values?
- cjfd 7y agoYou will find answers to 1 and 2 in https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0503009 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0503009
- paulddraper 7y agoOkay, let me rephrase. Many Worlds states that there is no collapse; the entanglement continue to propagate. Many Worlds is the familiar label for saying there's entanglement, and that's it. > 1. How does the Born rule arise? > 2. More generally, how does randomness arise? As you said, with Many Worlds there is no randomness. The multiverse is entirely deterministic. Randomness is a Copenhagen-like concept. There is a "universe" with an alive cat and a "universe" with a dead cat. These universes have a certain waveform distribution. Neither of these universe are any more real or extant than the other (they have the same magnitude).* * Though consciousness and its observations seems to follow only one path. This is a peculiarity outside the realm of physics.
- kgwgk 7y ago> This is a peculiarity outside the realm of physics. So the “realm of physics” is now disconnected from empirical reality? Great.
- russdill 7y agoI think more concisely, we don't understand it yet.
- paulddraper 7y ago> empirical reality Unfortunately, yes. Empirical reality is limited by the empiricist.
- kgwgk 7y agoSure. But I wouldn't say it's outside the realm of physics.
- 7y ago