2 ms·
Given that a Tesla weighs almost 2.5 Tonnes, I don't understand the desire to race them? Surely it will just perform like a bus under braking and roll around?
by mhh__ 7y ago
Given that a Tesla weighs almost 2.5 Tonnes, I don't understand the desire to race them? Surely it will just perform like a bus under braking and roll around?
They also don't have manual gearboxes, which is a turn off for me personally.
- dpark 7y ago> Surely it will just perform like a bus under braking and roll around? No. The center of gravity is extremely low because of all the batteries under the floor. It’s supposedly extremely stable under cornering. > They also don't have manual gearboxes If I recall correctly, they don’t have gearboxes in the traditional sense at all. They have single speed transmissions. But I might be wrong on this.
- freehunter 7y agoExactly. They could fake a manual gearbox but it would always just be a fakery. There is no shiftable gearbox at all, so it’s not an automatic vs manual transmission. It’s just an electric motor.
- mhh__ 7y agoIt's still very heavy, which is what I meant by bus. A Porsche 917K from the 70s can still outbrake some modern sports cars because of how light it is.
- dpark 7y agoYes, obviously it’s heavy. No, that doesn’t mean it feels like driving a bus. A go cart is far lighter than a Lotus Elise. Would you expect the Elise to feel like a bus in comparison?
- mhh__ 7y agoGo Karts are probably a slightly poor example given that they are probably the most direct driving you can get short of a cheap formula car
- dpark 7y agoAn Elise feels rather like a go-kart on steroids and amphetamines.
- MegaButts 7y agoI test drove a Model S years ago. It definitely felt like a bus the moment you turned the steering wheel. There is no substitute for weight reduction when it comes to handling.
- dharmab 7y agoMost electric vehicles- including all Teslas- have no need for a gearbox, as "first gear" is capable of 100mph+. Removing the gearbox reduces complexity and weight. Some electrics like the Empulse TT have included gearboxes to make operators transitioning from gas vehicles more comfortable. However, this did not catch on.
- mhh__ 7y agoAs said elsewhere, if I were buying a car to drive I'd want a manual gearbox because of the sensation of driving it. I know why Tesla's don't have gearboxes
- iknowstuff 7y agoDoesn't matter. This is an old Model S which lost solely due to its poor thermals. The Model 3, particularly with Track Mode enabled, sees very little performance degradation due to thermals. Keep in mind Teslas' low center of gravity due to the skateboard battery design. There is no need for a gearbox in a car with instant torque.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>There is no need for a gearbox in a car with instant torque. Depending on the system's ability/need to keep the motor cool that may or may not be true.
- mhh__ 7y agoIt's about the feel. I like shifting and doing heel-toe
- cromulent 7y agoTrue, unless you want maximum efficiency. Interestingly the Formula E cars are reducing the number of gears over time. https://www.hewland.com/formula-e-transmission-evolution/ https://www.hewland.com/formula-e-transmission-evolution/ One of the notable features of the new Porsche Taycan is the two speed gearbox. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20886641 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20886641