2 ms·
There is a paper by a member of a Norwegian research group that ran a pilot plant in the 1950's using iron sulfide as a starting material. I think their efficie
by Gibbon1 7y ago
There is a paper by a member of a Norwegian research group that ran a pilot plant in the 1950's using iron sulfide as a starting material. I think their efficiency was ~4kwh/kg. On a straight balance sheet it's not competitive against unexternalized fossil fuel based processes. It has the same problem I mentioned with hydrogen reduction. If you're using fossil fuels to create electricity to reduce iron, you can skip that generate electricity step and use the fossil fuel directly. Which is why there has been very little work in this area.
In a world where you have electricity from wind and solar with regular oversupply. And high taxes on carbon based fuels. then I think electrowinning is viable.
- marvin 7y agoFun fact, since you mentioned Norway -- in the early 1900s, Norwegian industry also used the Birkeland-Eyde process to produce nitric acid for fertilizer from atmospheric nitrogen. The process is not energy-competitive with other processes, but since the plants in question had very cheap hydropower energy that couldn't be exported for use elsewhere, this was not a dealbreaker. I'm thinking that energy-intensive industry in early hydropower-friendly regions could get away with using simple but inefficient processes, since the energy couldn't be used for anything better anyway. Sort of like creating a minimum viable product of an industrial process, before optimizing and getting great efficiency increases.