14 ms·
It's complicated, and it's going to take a long time for historians - and multiple books - to untangle the failure. But so far as I can tell it started because
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
It's complicated, and it's going to take a long time for historians - and multiple books - to untangle the failure.
But so far as I can tell it started because Bohr was a bit of a tyrant and didn't like having the Copenhagen Interpretation questioned. So that set the tone for the first few decades. And QM was still developing, so it was more important to solve specific problems than worry about generalities.
After that, progress was still being made on the Standard Model, so there was academic selection pressure pushing graduates towards PhD specifics and away from more philosophical speculations about Quantum Origins.
And after that the String Theory people were much better at aggressive self-promotion than any of the competing QG theories. So something related happened again.
Now there's no data to allow further fundamental progress on the Standard Model. SM alternatives continue being ruled out. And String Theory has run into very serious problems, So there's more interest in Quantum Origins and alternative QG theories. The odds of a big breakthrough are very low, they're higher than they used to be.
And also it's really kind of annoying not to understand what's happening.
- whatshisface 7y ago>And after that the String Theory people were much better at aggressive self-promotion than any of the competing QG theories. I'm not sure if that's a fair interpretation of history. At the time string theory still looked like the best option, and some say that even today it is the closest thing we have to a consistent theory.
- tim333 7y agoWas there ever a sting theory that looked plausible to explain gravity say? As far as I can tell it started off as a simple model of how the nucleus held together - to stop the protons flying apart lets model stings holding them together. And then after that it's been let's play with the maths and the aggressive self-promotion thing mostly.