4 ms·
Don’t you think your own recollection is a sample bias and a “plaster mask” (whatever that is supposed to mean) of your own?
by paulcole 7y ago
Don’t you think your own recollection is a sample bias and a “plaster mask” (whatever that is supposed to mean) of your own?
- dang 7y agoPlaster takes on the shape of what it surrounds and hardens into an inverse image of it. This is how people's memories of HN discussions work. You're more likely to notice the comments that seem wrong, unpleasant or offensive, and these make a deeper impression than the ones you agree with, so your image of HN hardens into the inverse image of your own views. People with the opposite views end up with the opposite image of HN. This explains why the claims they make are so contradictory, and why everyone with strong views ends up concluding that HN is on the side of what they dislike. It also explains the intensity aspect of the phenomenon: the intensity of how wrong people think HN is about X is predictable from how intensely they feel about X itself. That's weird if you think about it, but not so weird if you understand how this mechanism works. Do I think it applies to me too? Yes. The mechanism is so consistent that I believe it's universal. I'm sure it applies to many more things than HN too. What makes the moderator's position different is not that we aren't subject to those impressions, but that we're also subject to additional impressions. This happens when, every day for years, it's your job to read and reply to thousands (probably over a million by now) of posts users are making on the site, and evaluate them against a set of hopefully neutral guidelines. That view of the site, pounded in often enough, forces a different perspective over time. In other words, we have the same agree/disagree impulses that everyone else has, but there's also an additional set of "is it good for HN" impulses in how we react to these things. It's just the mechanical effect of doing anything a million times.