4 ms·
- You can have a transcendent experience without any drugs at all. - Your brain can perform [all] the chemical manipulations required in a much safer manner th
by mistermann 7y ago
- You can have a transcendent experience without any drugs at all.
- Your brain can perform [all] the chemical manipulations required in a much safer manner than e.g. flooding your system with synthetic LSD.
- If you have a therapeutic system that works in the first place then [drugs would be a sideshow [at best]].
- Adding LSD to ineffective scattershot therapies will just amplify random aspects of the subject's psychology.
The first point seems consistent with anything I've read on the subject, but the rest don't seem backed by anything I've read, if not contrary. (I've added brackets for emphasis on specific parts where applicable).
If you could point me in any direction to some reading I've missed it would be appreciated.
EDIT:
I assume the reply below ("Do not try to weasel out of this statement...") is directed at the parent to my post?
- AstralStorm 7y agoNo, the brain cannot flood itself with serotonin on demand ever. Dopamine, sort of maybe but only in extreme situations. Norepinephrine, maybe, likewise. Endocannabinoids, nope. Ampakines, way no. Glutamate, only in extreme conditions. Other neuropeptides, likely no. Do not try to weasel out of this statement without providing actual evidence that any "mental" treatment comes close to drug effects. Or other unsourced statements about "scattershot". Research had barely started. (Not efficacy. Efficacy requires also psychological work, which can be enhanced or retarded by drugs. Also to be evaluated.) Experiences are unrelated to efficacy for treatment most of the time, unless they are. I point you to studies of efficacy of prayer - not very.
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoI think a different threads of conversation are conflated here. Both parties are in an agreement, I suspect, that the LSD itself has no long term effect, as least as acute psychological treatment. The therapeutic value is in how you use the time. I think the parent poster who quoted O’Leary was saying that the drug is not necessary for the therapy to happen in the first place. Without that already reliable system of therapy in place, the chemical effects of the drug are not going to give consistently therapeutic results.
- AstralStorm 7y agoDo you mean like Prozac? :) Other ergoloids are used for breaking really hard to treat migraines. They work exceptionally well at that. MDMA or analog could be a novel antidepressant. Ibogaine (also a psychedelic) is already used for smoking cessation sometimes. Works relatively well, all things considered, but not without risks (cardiac). Now they're trialing it for alcoholism in Brazil. Maybe a chemical variant that is safer could be devised if not for the dumb prohibitions. And don't even start on THC and CBD.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- carapace 7y agoIn re: effective therapy I can recommend what's called Neurolinguistic Programming. It's pretty much an OS for the mind. Specifically, I can recommend two books on hypnosis: "TRANCE-Formations" by Bandler and Grinder, and "Monsters and Magical Sticks" by Steven Heller. For "higher" states of consciousness there is actually a simple and effective algorithm called "Core Transformation Process" It's taught by these folks: https://www.coretransformation.org/ https://www.coretransformation.org/ For the deeper spiritual aspects of psychological healing I can recommend the works of Sir David R. Hawkins, M.D., Ph.D., who was a very successful therapist who underwent enlightenment and has been able to describe it in terms accessible to the modern mind. https://veritaspub.com/dr-hawkins/#Biography%20Summary https://veritaspub.com/dr-hawkins/#Biography%20Summary
- mistermann 7y agoIndeed, there are a wide variety of approaches in this space (and I'm an advocate of combining multiple if necessary, the perfect approach is unknown, and varies by person), but any claims that they can achieve the same results (comprehensively) as psychedelics is a misrepresentation.
- carapace 7y agoDunno man, YMMV, I can "trip" on hypnosis all kinds of ways. I once (once) managed to have the "Kundalini" experience. It was wonderful. No drugs involved. Yet it was easily as psychedelic as any drug. I didn't try to do it again because I'm relatively conservative and I am not one to experiment with my own body recklessly. I.e. if something had gone wrong you can't show up at the emergency room and tell them "It was Kundalini" and expect them to have a coherent, educated response. This is a huge biological and psychological "event" or process (akin in depth and significance to orgasm) that is entirely unknown to Western medicine and science. Not only can the mind re-create drug states, it can also obviate actual drug states. (I.e. you can drink a pint of whiskey and remain sober.) > any claims that they can achieve the same results (comprehensively) as psychedelics is a misrepresentation. With caveats about the exact definitions of "they" and "results" and "comprehensively", I will go ahead and claim that the kind of results that people go to therapists to get can be got without using any external drugs at all, at all. Psychedelics just get you "high as a lord". They just shake up your thought-gland. Any therapeutic value they have is in the "set and setting", as Dr. Leary (the "LSD guy" himself) insists. If you want to get high, or just experience your subjectivity getting all jangly, then yeah LSD is great. If you want to solve your personal problems you can do that without taking drugs. It's not impossible to use psychedelics as part of a therapeutic system, but it's important to realize that there's no magic cure in the acid tab or magic mushroom. Just to wrap up, let me recommend "Sex and Drugs: A Journey Beyond Limits" by Robert Anton Wilson http://rawilson.com/sexdrugs.html http://rawilson.com/sexdrugs.html