7 ms·
If you are not a political undesirable, it does help, though. I think Wikipedia is fine in this regard, not something to shun of for a big corp.
by nine_k 7y ago
If you are not a political undesirable, it does help, though. I think Wikipedia is fine in this regard, not something to shun of for a big corp.
- dangxiaopin 7y agoThere's always something "undesirable" for someone in a big crowdsourced website.
- rocqua 7y agoThe cloudfare 8chan action was based on a direct link with multiple actual mass-shootings. Moreover, as they took the decision they went to great pains to explain this was an exceptional case. Going from that to 'undesired political speech will be censored' requires more of a slippery cliff than a slippery slope.
- gruez 7y ago>The cloudfare 8chan action was based on a direct link with multiple actual mass-shootings What is this "direct link" you speak of? Did the shooters plan/recruit/organize their attacks on 8chan?
- nl 7y agoThere are multiple instances of them announcing them and implying they are follow-ups of previous discussions on 8chan. These include the Christchurch shootings, the Poway synagogue shooting and the El Paso Walmart shootin. The Christchurch shooter shared his Facebook stream to 8chan before the shooting started, and it was spread from there. The Poway shooter blamed/thanked 8chan for his views.
- dangxiaopin 7y agoSo FB's internet peers should depeer Facebook then in their routers, since the original material (the stream) was on FB? Or you prefer your justice selective?
- nl 7y agoI'm sure you already realize this, but to make it clear: FB has enormous utility for billions of people outside that and that is worth defending. You are expanding a lot of effort defending 8chan here. Perhaps consider that it might not be worth defending.
- dangxiaopin 7y ago8ch had a lot of very interesting and non-violent stuff. Have you been reading it regularly? I did. I lived in a socialist country and you did not. Perhaps consider that you might not know where these current trends are pointing to.
- nl 7y agoI lived in a socialist country I'm glad you understand the risks associated with any kind of absolute positions then. There's a good reason why most of the world is entirely comfortable with restricting the ability of extremists to spread their shit.
- marvin-83 7y agoyou're not really engaging with his point. Effectively banning 8chan by removing network protection does not just restrict extremists; it restricts anyone who used that forum. Ultimately, such matters should be prosecuted by courts. It is inappropriate for organisations like cloudflare to leverage their position within essential network infrastructure to start editorialising what passes through their network.
- nl 7y agoIt is inappropriate for organisations like cloudflare to leverage their position within essential network infrastructure to start editorialising what passes through their network. No, I think it's entirely appropriate. "Don't troll" and methods for dealing with trolls has been a thing all sites have done since the internet was invented. I don't see any difference here at all.
- rocqua 7y agoThe direct link is that they announced these attacks there. Beyond that, given the announcement there, it stands to reason they were convinced to do it there.
- speedplane 7y ago> What is this "direct link" you speak of? Did the shooters plan/recruit/organize their attacks on 8chan? Legally, a "direct link" is irrelevant, you can rarely find a "direct link" between two of anything. What matters legally is whether 8chan was a "proximate cause" in creating the mass shootings. Whether one thing is the "proximate cause" of another is often pretty difficult to discern. However, as a helpful guide towards determining proximate cause, lawyers ask whether one thing was the "but for" cause of another, i.e., would the mass shootings occur "but for" 8Chan? Put another way, if 8Chan did not exist, would these shootings occur? Unfortunately, we do not have an alternative reality to play out events without 8Chan, so we cannot know for certain, but we can use evidence (e.g., 8Chan chats, how the shooter interacted with 8Chan and others on the service, etc) to try to simulate that alternative reality. All of this analysis also needs to consider related issues like freedom of speech on public forums and any commercial interests. I'm not saying 8Chan is guilty or innocent, just that the existence (or lack thereof) of a "direct link" is pretty meaningless.
- wwright 7y agoI think it’s somewhat misleading to refer to those who support genocide and child abuse as simply “political undesirables.”
- nine_k 7y agoThey are beyond a certain line; some very-very far past it, some just crossed it. It makes them unsupportable by any corporation that aims to look decent.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 7y agoIt's not just supporting. Taking a neutral stance on censoring these things, or not being adequately proactive on hate speech, is now seen as condoning. You either censor your user base, or upstream will censor you. Gone are the days of "The net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." The new policy is "The net interprets wrongthink as noise and filters it out."
- wwright 7y agoIt’s not censorship: they are not suppressing information, they just aren’t allowing their resources to be used to spread it. It would be “censorship” if they actively antagonized any attempt to spread the information, such as by lawsuit or DMCA notice. They are just refusing to participate. And given that the “information” is definitively known to be child pornography and violent white supremacy propaganda presented as news, I would personally say refusing to participate is the only responsible action.
- claudiawerner 7y ago> Gone are the days of "The net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." But it's clear that it matters just what's being censored. Surely you wouldn't say the same trite clever-sounding hackerspeak if we're talking about censorship of threats, assault and child pornography, would you?
- 7y ago
- sannee 7y agoWikipedia is blocked in China. It's politically undesirable for 1/8 of the human population...
- nine_k 7y agoUnlike a DDoS attack, this is not a technological problem.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoI think undesirable here describes something like white nationalists. They have a problem getting web hosting.
- sannee 7y agoCloudFlare has strategic business partnership with Baidu [1]. They are very likely to cooperate with the chinese government to implement the great chinese firewall. Additionally, helping to block Wikipedia because China says so is much easier to excuse than blocking 4chan - they would just be complying with local regulations after all. [1] https://www.cloudflare.com/press-releases/2015/cloudflare-and-baidu-announce-strategic-partnership-to-help-build-a-better-internet/ https://www.cloudflare.com/press-releases/2015/cloudflare-an...
- allard 7y agoBecause all of them don't want it?