5 ms·
I'll just say this and take my downvotes[1]: It's impossible to read a piece like this in the modern world, about two white middle class families leaving large
by ajross 7y ago
I'll just say this and take my downvotes[1]: It's impossible to read a piece like this in the modern world, about two white middle class families leaving large, coastal multiethnic metropolises for suburban homes in (what a quick google tells me is) the sixth whitest state in the union, without a racial lens.
These workers "fleeing" big cities simply don't seem likely to be a uniformly sampled demographic, and for the article not to at least nod to that seems like pretty questionable journalism.
But maybe that's just a step too woke.
[1] Edit: heh, two minutes before the first accusation of racism. Pretty much what I expected.
- someguydave 7y agoPeople who think every human decision revolves around race are racist.
- selimthegrim 7y agoYou’re missing the point. Would a visibly brown family have the same latitude?
- someguydave 7y agoTreating people as objects of pity because of their race is racist.
- umeshunni 7y agoI dunno, man, most of my (Indian-American) family lives out in the Midwest and not in some hipster coastal city.
- ajross 7y agoYeah, but the Boise sprawl neighborhoods detailed in the article are almost certainly 95+% white. It's not like there's no diversity in "the midwest", but the Idaho places being described (and lovingly photographed!) are awfully segregated. Would you or your extended family really be comfortable packing up and moving into an environment where they're literally the only south asians in their neighborhood? If not, then that seems like an important fact to address in an article about large scale population motion. It just creeps me out. The article is nominally about a fairly bland economic point, but the archetype they picked is a bunch of (seriously, really beautiful) photos of white families in de facto segregated neighborhoods!
- drak0n1c 7y agoMy spouse's family was one of the only Chinese American families in their small Wyoming town. Her father moved to there poor and is now a VP at the local employer and heads multiple local organizations. The first time she experienced actual harmful racism was after moving to Seattle. All it takes is a willingness to put yourself out there, attend a local church, etc. The people I’ve ran into there are far friendlier and more genuine than nearly everyone I’ve met in my years of city living.
- selimthegrim 7y agoMy aunt in a small town in rural Florida was visibly brown and Muslim (well, Ahmedi, but that's not important for this post). She described getting relentlessly proselytized at her doorstep, at the A&P, every Sunday, etc. Attending a local church wasn't an option.
- someguydave 7y agoI know several Indians who live in nearly all white suburbs and they get along just fine.
- masonic 7y agoThe most NIMBY people I've ever encountered are Cupertino residents from the subcontinent.
- selimthegrim 7y agoThere’s a world of difference between say Cleveland, OH and Zanesville.
- tathougies 7y agoI mean I'm brown and I left san francisco for a smaller city. Although unlike most people here I actually liked the san Francisco area and the 'rat race' and would like to live there but it is cheaper outside of course
- sgustard 7y agoI completely agree. "White flight" is not a new phenomenon, despite attempts to re-brand it. I'd love to hear cases of people of color moving to smaller cities while retaining a sense of community and belonging.
- ajross 7y agoTo be fair: there's lots of population movement everywhere, in every demographic. There's even an infographic that shows arrows pointing to quite diverse spots like Vegas and Orlando. But the text of the article is all about white people moving to Boise (with a few other nods to similarly white destinations). And to write that, in 2019, without so much as a nod that maybe this isn't really representative and maybe there's a less wholesome motion afoot just sets my alarm bells off. Seriously: that article is straight up about white flight. The data might not be, but the article absolutely is.
- defen 7y ago"White flight" is when you leave because minorities are moving in. The people interviewed in the article were moving for economic reasons.
- ajross 7y agoIt is? Go back and find me a 1950's source that credits the growth of the American Suburban Lifestyle to a desire for racial segregation. The racial subtext became clear only decades later. Almost no one, even in the 50's, actually claimed to be a "racist". Be real. And this article? It tickles all the same creepy buttons. It defines a "good" thing, and enumerates its benefits, in terms that "just happen" to be a bunch of pro-segregation dynamics.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- a3n 7y agoI had similar thoughts/assumptions when I noticed in the graphic that people leaving New York and Chicago are back tracking the same paths taken 100 years earlier when the industrial North attracted people who needed out of the south.
- bluthru 7y agoOf course it's a factor. For the most part people like to be part of their own tribe. It's human nature, not taboo.
- masonic 7y agothe sixth whitest state You conflate the ethnic makeup of the city they flee with that of their destination state. In contrast, New York state as a whole is predominantly white, while I would guess that Boise is the most diverse city in Idaho.
- ajross 7y agoYou're right. I should have looked it up. Here: > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_percentage_of_white_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... Boise is in fact the THIRD whitest city in the whole country .
- masonic 7y agoYou're misinterpreting your source. Putting aside the qualifiers that the dataset[0] is specific to cities with population above 100K and that it's a decade old, the counts include Hispanics and whites together, which is obvious from Laredo, Corpus Christi, and El Paso all being in the top 8. In other words, using your source, Boise is all of 1.3 percentage points whiter than Laredo, Texas. [0] https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/united-states/quick-facts/cities/rank/white-population-percentage https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/united-states/quick-facts/c...