4 ms·
Aside from not providing much of any performance benefit, this will introduce difficulty coordinating regenerative braking through the shift point. One of my f
by phkahler 7y ago
Aside from not providing much of any performance benefit, this will introduce difficulty coordinating regenerative braking through the shift point.
One of my former employers had a group trying really hard to make a 2-speed for EVs make sense. It just doesn't. If there is an efficiency gain, it's probably better to throw the extra money and weight into the motor. An exception might be if you want to cruise at 120+ mph for long distances, but that's not realistic.
- youeseh 7y agoWhich part of cruising at 120+ mph for long distances is not realistic?
- NDizzle 7y agoLong distances?
- sdfswfsafaswf 7y ago1. outside Germany, cops 2. power scales as v^3 destroying range.
- Gibbon1 7y agoWe shouldn't lose sight of #3. 3. This is a toy we're talking about here.
- lazyjones 7y agoI eagerly await to see the Taycan's range at 120+ mph. evcalc.ch suggests it would be around 164 Km for 200 Km/h (Turbo S).
- GhostVII 7y agoWhy don't you think there will be much performance benefit? The Porsche taycan is much faster accelerating than any Tesla at high speeds, probably due to the two speed gearbox. I don't think it is an efficiency thing, electric motors just start loosing power after a certain rpm, and a gearbox helps with this.
- paganel 7y agoCruising at 120+ mph on long distances happens a lot on German autobahns, one of Porsche’s main markets.
- fluffything 7y agoI drive from Ingolstadt to Bonn regularly and on average I am able to get ~170km/h average speed for the trip. If I'm lucky (e.g. at night) I surpass ~180km/h. That requires a lot of cruising at 250km/h. Starting with a full tank I still end up with gas to spare. I had a Ford Focus 10 years ago and I remember managing ~150km/h average speed for the trip without refuelling... If I need to charge an EV once for 20 min to be able to complete the trip then the car probably does not make sense for this use case. An Opel Corsa would finish the trip faster, for a fraction of the price. Now if you give me an EV that can do 500km at >180km/h avg speed without recharging under normal german traffic conditions (lots of 250km/h mixed with lots of 130km/h) and is still left with some power for a bit of city driving then that would be an improvement.