3 ms·
> Multispeed transmissions must be robust to deal with the massive amounts of torque that electric motors can generate in a very short period of time, says Shas
by kazinator 7y ago
> Multispeed transmissions must be robust to deal with the massive amounts of torque that electric motors can generate in a very short period of time, says Shashank Sripad, a mechanical engineer also from Carnegie Mellon.
Put a manual clutch on it; problem solved. Manual boxes can be built strong.
Then make it at least a 3 speed so there is a decent H pattern there from the stick user's perspective, and so that the ratio isn't so large (it's like around 2X change¹, supposedly! That means the motor's RPM has to drop by by half on upshift and double on downshift.)
3 speeds could use a 1.44 step.
1 3
| |
+--
| \
2 R = V/I
---
1. Source: this article claims the gears are 16:1 and 8.05:1. https://jalopnik.com/an-extremely-detailed-look-at-the-porsche-taycans-engin-1837802533 https://jalopnik.com/an-extremely-detailed-look-at-the-porsc...
- GhostVII 7y agoIf you put a manual gearbox in it, I bet a single bad shift would tear it apart with all that torque at low RPM. Also would probably kill the clutch unless you are a really good driver, and it is hard to shift when you can't hear the engine RPM. And I don't think manual gearboxes are any stronger than a well built automatic but I have nothing to back that up except intuition.
- kazinator 7y ago> it is hard to shift when you can't hear the engine RPM. A third-rate hardware tinkerer could come up with a circuit that makes a motorboating sound from a speaker at the engine RPM. That could be heard just during shifting activity, like when the clutch is out. > Also would probably kill the clutch. It would require a special clutch design. The clutch is not needed when starting, of course, because since the motor can generate torque right from zero RPM, the transmission can be engaged. A clutch mechanism needed when changing gears due to the mismatch in speeds that needs to be bridged. The existing two-speeder must have something serving as a clutch, just not a manually operated one. Speaking at torque at zero RPM; can't that be modulated down somehow? Surely there must be some way of managing the motor to bring in torque gently. This must be happening already, right? I mean, electric cars don't burn rubber each time they get moving. > I don't think manual gearboxes are any stronger than a well built automatic That's easy; just define the requirements for "well built" so that it is so, and don't care about weight, size, and other things. The automatic transmission from a bus is probably stronger than the manual in an econobox car.