3 ms·
> Yeah, but no publicly trusted certs. > (Over 1.5M expire in the 2040s alone!) I doubt ~75% of the self signed certs expire in this dataset expire 21-30 year
by zamadatix 7y ago
> Yeah, but no publicly trusted certs.
> (Over 1.5M expire in the 2040s alone!)
I doubt ~75% of the self signed certs expire in this dataset expire 21-30 years from now. Surely the author is correct that there are a good number of public certs with a very long expiration. Would need to download and filter the dataset to know for sure though.
- tialaramex 7y agoI doubt anybody has ever issued a "real" (Web PKI) leaf certificate (leaves are the edge of the tree, the certificates presented by TLS servers this work connected to) for 21 years let alone 30. Back in 2011 when the Baseline Requirements were first written, they set 60 months (5 years) as the upper limit, with the intent to further restrict to 39 months in a few years and that eventually happened in 2015 or so. Last year 39 months went down to 825 days and there's currently pressure to reduce it further in 2020. Note that it's not just self-signed certs you'd be considering, many of the certs in this dataset will be issued by a CA but not a public CA. Could be an internal CA (e.g. Windows Server provides software to run one, so does RHEL) or could even be one of the private-use-only CAs run by the same companies that operate public CAs. There were about half a million certs in that dataset issued by SomeOrganization with email address root@localhost.localdomain. Not technically self-signed, but obviously that's not a public CA.
- Bombthecat 7y agoWith raising automation of issuance for certificates (I might work soon on a project to add an api to issue certificatates) I don't see any reason to not go any lower. Like just a few days or weeks.
- jlawer 7y agoThat doesn't work if your running software supplied by a vendor that needs an SSL certificate. Often they have manual processes, that require shutting down the application and restarting, taking the service offline through the process. These applications are also frequently heavily firewalled to the internet so security risks are limited, but not with smaller operations, you might not have PKI infrastructure in place to manage your own root certs (especially in BYOD orgs). If a certificate rollover takes your application offline for an hour, your not going to want to do it every week.