7 ms·
They are in a no-win position and keeping silent is worse. Android security has always been a bit of a contradiction of terms, and while Google has improved th
by Spooky23 7y ago
They are in a no-win position and keeping silent is worse.
Android security has always been a bit of a contradiction of terms, and while Google has improved the OS, the combination of limited availability of upgrades due to carrier nonsense and the state of apps on the platform. An Android zeroday isn’t news.
The iOS defects are particularly jarring as they have been rare to date.
- mandevil 7y agoThis is not what Zerodium says[1]. They claim, and are backing it up with millions of dollars, that current Android exploits are more valuable than current iOS, because of a large supply of iOS issues. [1]: https://www.wired.com/story/android-zero-day-more-than-ios-zerodium/ https://www.wired.com/story/android-zero-day-more-than-ios-z...
- Spooky23 7y agoIn the article they discuss that it’s lkelly a publicity stunt.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoNo, it says they might be trying to influence market prices. Another researcher quoted in the article confirms that the market price for an exploit of a high end Android device is 30% more than an equivalent iOS exploit and gives Safari's poor security as the reason. Despite Safari having such a large attack surface, iOS cannot update it without a reboot, which only exacerbates the problem.
- mandevil 7y ago0dium's actual prices are likely a publicity stunt, but it says quite clearly, citing several different, independent sources, that attacks against a fully patched Android system are now worth more than the equivalent attack against a fully patched iOS machine. That is in part because Android has hardened up recently, Safari and iMessage in particular are highly vulnerable, and also because there was more money recently in iOS and so there was more attention on it. To a certain extent, of course, attacks against Android outside of flagship Samsung and Google phones are much cheaper- look at any patchset and attack, and given that 30+% of the Android user base is on Nougat/Oreo and 10% is on Kitkat or earlier as a whole they are far more exposed.
- scarface74 7y agoApple uses the same carriers as Google. The poor state of Android updates is no one’s fault but Google’s. No matter where I buy my Windows PC from, my upgrades come from Microsoft. In fact, I have an ancient Mac Mini that can still receive Windows 7 updates.
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoThey weren't referring to the networks themselves. Carriers release (or work with manufacturers to release) versions of phones with a bunch of custom stuff added onto a vanilla Android OS. When Google releases a new OS or an important security fix to Android, carriers need to merge this stuff in with all of their custom stuff, assuming that they still care to do so and support that device. As a result, phones running Android can fall years behind on patches. The phones sold by Apple don't have this problem. The phones sold by Google also don't have this problem. But the phones sold by carriers but running Google's OS have this problem. Phones sold by carriers but running Apple's OS would also have this problem, but Apple doesn't let anyone else sell phones with their OS. The difference between your computer's patches and your phone's patches is that you are allowed to update your computer's operating system, but your phone has probably been carefully locked down by your carrier to prevent you being able to do this, which is very upsetting but that's a different matter.
- scarface74 7y agoCarriers release (or work with manufacturers to release) versions of phones with a bunch of custom stuff added onto a vanilla Android OS. PC makers also put various crapware on phones and use to do shell replacements. That never stopped anyone from upgrading... When Google releases a new OS or an important security fix to Android, carriers need to merge this stuff in with all of their custom stuff, assuming that they still care to do so and support that device. As a result, phones running Android can fall years behind on patches. Microsoft also allowed various carrier changes to Windows Phones but they could still offer upgrades across devices. Phones sold by carriers but running Apple's OS would also have this problem, but Apple doesn't let anyone else sell phones with their OS. Microsoft has had a vibrant ecosystem of third parties selling PCs running its OS for decades. The entire idea behind WinHec and Plug and Play in the mid 90s was to solve this very problem. The issue that either Google doesn’t know how to properly run a platform or didn’t make it a priority. You see that Google can architect a system where Google Play Services can be updated across manufacturers. They care enough to keep their spying mechanism updated. The difference between your computer's patches and your phone's patches is that you are allowed to update your computer's operating system, but your phone has probably been carefully locked down by your carrier to prevent you being able to do this, which is very upsetting but that's a different matter. That’s only because Apple wrested control from the carriers before any iPhone shipped to keep carrier crap off their phone and to keep control over its devices. Google never cared to. Android is just a badly architected system in this regard. Microsoft solved this problem two decades ago.