5 ms·
Attorney here! What act, specifically, do you believe is illegal, and what laws make it so?
by otterley 7y ago
Attorney here! What act, specifically, do you believe is illegal, and what laws make it so?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 7y agoYou make a good point. The article is light on specifics so it's hard to determine how they made the request. It says "court order" which, as you know, could mean a number of things. That said, no court should be approving any demand for this data. It's 100% fishing.
- dbcurtis 7y agoSearch without probable cause.
- phkahler 7y agoIs it? They are asking to search Apple and Google, not individuals. Maybe they have a reason not to limit the data to people outside the country - like finding out who is actually shipping the scopes to restricted countries. If people are concerned, maybe they need to download and install apps some other way.
- dbcurtis 7y ago> They are asking to search Apple and Google, not individuals. They are asking Apple and Google to tell them what individuals have on their phones. They are in a very practical and concrete sense searching the phones of individuals. > If people are concerned, maybe they need to download and install apps some other way. For an iPhone? Spell that method out for me, I am keen to learn.
- fencepost 7y agoWelcome to the cloud. They're asking for information stored on servers that you don't control or own. Pretty sure the same thing applies to a lot of cloud storage email. If the FBI wants all of your email and you have a Gmail account, are they going to subpoena it from you or from Google? That's where part of the difference between cloud storage like Dropbox and spideroak show up.
- salawat 7y agoI'd say lack of probable cause, and the process being essentially a fishing expedition. Last I checked, there had to be clear evidence linking a particular individual to a potential criminal act before a warrant could be issued. I.e. it's fine for the government to phrase the warrant "give us all info with regards to users/downloaders with GeoIP's outside the United States" as the being in possession of the product outside the country at least correlates with the possibility of being an ITAR violator. Even then it is sketchy, because that would be a separate charge technically, because they are only the receiver, not the exporter necessarily. On the other hand, demanding all the info to cross reference with an internal licensing database seems an egregious overstep, and an exploitation of an overly broad warrant. It sets a very bad precedent in terms of allowable conduct.
- otterley 7y ago> Last I checked, there had to be clear evidence linking a particular individual to a potential criminal act before a warrant could be issued. (This is not legal advice. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.) Not so. The Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure apply here, particularly Rule 41. https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcrmp/rule_41 https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcrmp/rule_41 See particularly section (c): (c) Persons or Property Subject to Search or Seizure. A warrant may be issued for any of the following: (1) evidence of a crime; (2) contraband, fruits of crime, or other items illegally possessed; (3) property designed for use, intended for use, or used in committing a crime; or (4) a person to be arrested or a person who is unlawfully restrained. -- Nor does an individual need to be identified. "John Does" are commonly enumerated as defendants in criminal indictments, and warrants can be used as a means to locate them. The bar for what constitutes "probable cause" is also quite low. Even anonymous tips can give rise to PC. See, e.g., Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (1983). https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/462/213/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/462/213/
- salawat 7y agoAgain, I'd argue that (1) Evidence of a crime means "We have reason to expect John Doe of Whereveristan has committed an ITAR violation. We believe He did so through his Android device. We need the information associated with his account... So on and so forth." That is tightly constrained, states the desired information to be turned over, the subject (individual) of the warrant, and the alleged reason why it is necessary. "We want all users account information containing entry XYZ because maybe, possibly, some subset of that corpus of individuals may have committed a crime" does not meet that standard. By allowing this type of fishing expedition it completely upends the notion of presumed innocence, and encourages broad, sweeping warrants to be considered an acceptable investigative technique. Something that has been continually rebuked over the last century, and has only started to crumble since the introduction of Third Party Doctrine. >Nor does an individual need to be identified. "John Does" are commonly enumerated as defendants in criminal indictments, and warrants can be used as a means to locate them. Huh. I knew of the John Doe practice, but I didn't realize it was used to conduct legal proceedings in absentia the individual in hopes of eventually finding an individual that "fits" the allegation. Not sure how to feel about that. Thanks for the input though! Today I learned! EDIT: On further reflection, I suppose it shouldn't surprise me. Obviously there has to be a legal construct to enable the legal system to move forward and react to ongoing criminal developments in the case where the perpetrator is highly effective in covering their tracks, and law enforcement has to piece things together from the effects of the crime until such time as enough coincidence occurs to narrow the list of suspects to a particular individual.
- willis936 7y agoThe 14th amendment. The judicial system has consistently ruled that the government cannot make lists of potential criminals without due process.
- otterley 7y agoThe 14th Amendment doesn't speak to how warrants are issued; that's the 4th amendment. (Please don't recite the text of the amendment to me - the governing law is what matters.) We haven't seen the affidavit provided to the court in pursuit of the warrant. Without it, we simply cannot conclude why the warrant was issued, only that it was issued. I worked once for a Federal district court. If the judge who issued this warrant was anything like my judge, they would question the affiant (usually an FBI Agent or other LE officer) to make sure they were on solid ground. My judge was definitely not a pushover. In several cases, the affiants had identified a particular individual and were requesting the warrant to locate evidence of who might be the co-conspirators.