4 ms·
Housing isn't a free market, it's heavily regulated, with a healthy amount of influence from wealthy interests going into that regulation. Like, how do you obs
by maxerickson 7y ago
Housing isn't a free market, it's heavily regulated, with a healthy amount of influence from wealthy interests going into that regulation.
Like, how do you observe the stagnation and not connect it to regulation?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThat was just an example, meant to foster meaningful commentary. But let me give it a try: Limited tax income (we all vote on that), geometric expansion of infrastructure cost as city radius grows, 'bow wave' of old insufficient infrastructure buried under the old city that cost bundles to remediate...you can go on and on. I know its fun to pretend conspiracies are everywhere, and the man is keeping you down. But there are real reasons for things, and its more helpful to know them. Especially if you plan on voting.
- mindslight 7y agoOn the supply side, building height and density are directly regulated by local politics. On the demand side, the asset price trend of housing / land is directly chosen by the central government when it picks interest rates. It's foolish to say that the housing market is anything resembling a free market. And brushing off discussion of specific mechanisms of causality as "conspiracy" is just intellectual laziness.
- maxerickson 7y agoIt isn't even a conspiracy. Lots of people loudly and overtly oppose policies that might lower housing costs (or even just increase supply enough to reduce the rate of increase).
- mindslight 7y agoThe word "conspiracy" is often used to avoid talking about general motives of individual actors that lead to some emergent behavior. It's basically a combination of an ad-hominem (claiming unreasonable paranoia) and straw man (the high bar of some secretive cabal meeting). Even before rising to the level of explicit policy, existing residents are generally against new development because it will eg take away open space they've come to take for granted. I actually just had the pleasure of observing a town meeting over environmental concerns for a new development, and one abutter shamelessly asserted the area would be better kept as park (completely out of the scope of this commission). Of course the real answer for how to control adjacent land is to buy it (possibly communally), and then enact your will, but a whole host of issues makes this unwieldy in the US.
- mcguire 7y ago"On the supply side, building height and density are directly regulated by local politics." Would you prefer that the residents have no input into local conditions? In most cities I've lived, developers had all of the power in local politics because they had the money. That didn't go well either. "On the demand side, the asset price trend of housing / land is directly chosen by the central government when it picks interest rates." Hoards of people moving into a constrained area with a shit ton of money clearly have no effects. And how is "the central government" not a conspiracy theory?
- maxerickson 7y agoYes, I consistently vote in favor of local tax increases.
- mikepurvis 7y agoJust blaming "regulation" without qualification is a little vague for my tastes. There are important reasons why we don't just allow anyone to come along and build anything anywhere. Some of those reasons are really good— neighbourhood character, height limits, flood/ecology/watershed management, traffic management, etc. And some are bad or over-used, like parking minimums, and the various barriers that prevent density and walkability upgrades (low-rises, multi-unit conversions, mixed use development).
- maxerickson 7y agoNeighborhood character and height restrictions aren't "really good", they are maybe okay sometimes. Traffic management is a planning problem, but it isn't a reason to not build things (for instance, if you refuse to build things for traffic management and limit density, you probably just end up with more traffic anyway...).
- rayiner 7y agoOnly watershed management is a legitimate reason for regulation out of your list.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoAnd even then it's not a hard limit. You can always pull a Boston and get the state to let you take the water from a poorer area with plenty of water.
- mcguire 7y agoAs an aside, Georgia periodically tries to claim a chunk of Tennessee to get access to the Tennessee River. "“I just want to threaten them and then stick a straw into the Tennessee River,” state Senate President Pro Tempore Butch Miller, R-Gainesville, said during a hearing..." (2018) If you have been through north Georgia recently, you probably noticed that all of the lake levels are very low. Atlanta takes a lot of water.
- jandrese 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mc32 7y agoRegulation means you don’t get half-arsed made houses that have no fire alarms or come down in the middle of the night, have no running water or have dangerous electrical work and follow no building codes... the kind of housing we used to see in pre-WWII shanty-town housing. That’s the other extreme to government only-housing (i.e. socialist economy housing). We’re in the middle somewhere and sometimes NIMBYism gets the best of us, but Houston is a decent counterexample.
- 8ytecoder 7y agoI think the OP is referring to zoning regulation and not housing regulation. Zoning in the Bay Area is truly horrendous. There's vast swaths of land that's mandatory detached single home only. Some cities in the Bay Area, for example, even ban a second storey.
- maxerickson 7y agoI wasn't really being specific, I was simply addressing the statement that housing prices are a 'free' market, which they aren't. There are probably good zoning type regulations (things like controls on industrial activities) and there are certainly excessive building regulations. The classic problem of regulation is doing it right, not the question of doing it vs not doing it.