4 ms·
Here's my pie-in-the-sky concept for an Etsy reboot: 1. Member-owned. There are so many details, but the idea is to align the company directly with the values
by carapace 7y ago
Here's my pie-in-the-sky concept for an Etsy reboot:
1. Member-owned. There are so many details, but the idea is to align the company directly with the values of the members.
2. Grow by IRL social graph, with people inviting and vouching for new members. You can't sign up from the web, only from in-person contacts. Probably hardware-backed (Yubikey or whatever). Web-of-Trust... handwave!
3. Open business. Radical openness and honesty as in "Honest Business: A Superior Strategy for Starting and Managing Your Own Business" by Salli Rasberry & Michael Phillips https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/22105625-honest-business https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/22105625-honest-business
4. Minimum prices, high. Like a baseline of US$150. I'm seriously. The #1 problem most Etsy sellers have is they set their prices too low. The market should foster the idea in customers' heads that their purchases are deliberate economic decisions to support a given person IRL as an independent creative success. You also get a fantastic scarf or whatever.
5. Straight-up handmade. No compromises. This is a showcase and marketplace for artisans and creators.
6. Explicit focus on the growth and success of the members. Things like organizing free classes on running a business, maybe tied in with SCORE ( https://www.score.org/ https://www.score.org/ ) or something. I think there should be an option for members to have public goals and meters for themselves like e.g. Kickstarter. I'd also like to have "plans" available to outline the paths to certain levels of success. Like, Plan A "Comfortable life in the country, plus good health insurance." to Plan O "Be the next Oprah".
7. Along those lines, there should be specific help for IP: developing it and protecting it, and paths to automated production. If there's a demand for your style or product the market should help you fulfill it, as opposed to having third parties rip off your designs and order imitations from rapid-turn-around factories. This has to be harmonized with the idea that the primary market is strictly handmade only. You shouldn't be punished for making something so popular it's pirated. The modern automatic economy should be a service, not a competitor.
8. There should be a kind of graduation when a member becomes successful enough on their own that they don't need the marketplace anymore. I'm not sure of the details here because I don't mean that they should be kicked out or anything like that, but rather that, once you've "made it", your role should shift a bit to where you're helping others reach their success.
9. All-in-all, double-down on the idea that we're really creating a viable new economy here. Emphasize tracking the supply chains and try to ground them in ecological sources. Have explicit ratings and discussions of the sources for raw materials. People who live off grid should have some sort of extra oomph, like badges to display or something. Promote sustainable, or better yet regenerative, economy.
- onemoresoop 7y agoI was thinking about the same thing. The money could be deducted from the fee they add to the sales. VC capital and fast growth are toxic