3 ms·
Windows doesn’t really have a window manager like the concept from X11. Basically the apps get messages and by using the standard libraries to handle a selectio
by tinus_hn 7y ago
Windows doesn’t really have a window manager like the concept from X11. Basically the apps get messages and by using the standard libraries to handle a selection of messages, you get the behavior you’d expect of a Windows app, like the maximizing and minimizing, resizing and the Windows 10 specific zooming behavior. But there is little coordination and no separate process that draws window frames or something like that.
Also normal apps can’t send messages to elevated apps because there are ways to take over apps by sending the messages that you can’t really defend against.
- simias 7y agoThank you for confirming my intuitions, I wasn't entirely sure if it was a hard limitation of the way Windows handled... windows or if it was just buggy software. So I guess this new WM suffers from the same limitations? This experience actually made me wary of Wayland and other X11 replacements because, as far as I understand, they behave similarly. I could be completely wrong about that though because I still haven't completely figured out how Wayland actually works and every time I looked for infos on this particular topic I ended up more confused than when I started.
- jowsie 7y agoI can confirm PowerToys does need to run as admin for this functionality.
- jhoechtl 7y agoSway is a Wayland only WM and doesn't suffer of any the shortcomings you describe.
- michaelmrose 7y agoEach wayland compositor is like a combination of X and a singular wm wherein the existing Wayland standard provides a framework for implementing rather than each person reinventing their own x alternative.
- contextfree 7y agoThis is true for Win32 apps but window management of UWP apps is more coordinated, with a process that draws all the window frames.