5 ms·
Selling fan-art should honestly just be allowed at this point. There are a lot of rules that should be in place like not being able to directly use the official
by Spivak 7y ago
Selling fan-art should honestly just be allowed at this point. There are a lot of rules that should be in place like not being able to directly use the official assets or labeling that it's 3rd-party and not endorsed but these kinds of things should be able to operate above board.
The current system of "don't get on the copyright holder's bad side" is silly.
- jplayer01 7y ago> Selling fan-art is just a copyright loophole that should honestly just be plugged at this point. Or we should stop letting companies monopolize markets and become insanely rich off of that thing they came up with 30 years ago. Plug it? Tear it wide fucking open.
- Spivak 7y agoI don't disagree with you but I think perfect is the enemy of good in this case. Changing copyright a little bit to allow fan-art is a much smaller problem than dismantling copyright in it's entirety and we can work on both.
- Nasrudith 7y agoSerious question - what is the purpose served in closing that loophole? What damages are averted or gains realized to society? I agree the current system is silly but I don't think going more restrictive is the answer. What if anything should be permissible? Would say for instance - you can commission a Master Sword copy or make one and sell it but manufacturing them enmasse be verbotten?
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThere is no loophole. Infringement is infringement even if you're small potatoes and haven't been sued yet. This isn't a fair use issue when you're engaged in commercial sale of appropriated works.
- Spivak 7y agoOkay sure, maybe loophole was poor wording but my point is that this really shouldn't be considered infringement and that you should be able to sell fan-art.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoIt shouldn't be infringement... because you don't want it to? There is nothing special about fan art that lets you break the law even if some copyright/trademark holders have a benevolent attitude toward it.
- Spivak 7y agoYeah, I mean that pretty much the gist of how most laws work. The market for fan-art is absolutely massive which operates in a weird limbo of being de facto licensed as long as the copyright holder likes it or if there would be public outcry if it was taken down. The current system is kinda stupid. Copyright holders have no incentive to license because reserving the right to sue but not suing is used instead. This is the problem that needs to be addressed. I want to live in the universe where the resolution is that fan-art is not considered infringement and doesn’t need licensing compared to the universe where the resolution is that all not explicitly licensed art disappears.
- wool_gather 7y ago> It shouldn't be infringement... because you don't want it to? Well, yes. That's how laws like copyright work; it's an agreement that we've made to try to achieve some result, with bonuses and tradeoffs. If we decide some part of it isn't working out, then we tweak it to alter the outcomes.