4 ms·
> If a black hole is obeying thermodynamic laws, we can presume that a statistical description of all its fundamental, indivisible parts can be made. No. It is
by gus_massa 7y ago
> If a black hole is obeying thermodynamic laws, we can presume that a statistical description of all its fundamental, indivisible parts can be made.
No. It is posible to define the entropy of an object that has no internal indivisible parts, for example a black hole.
> Here’s another way in which the analogy falls flat. Black hole entropy is given by the black hole area. Well, area is length squared, volume is length cubed. So what do we make of all those thermodynamic relations that include volume, like Boyle’s law? Is volume, which is length times area, really length times entropy? That would ruin the analogy. So we have to say that volume is not the counterpart of volume, which is surprising.
This paragraph makes no sense at all. No sense at all!
First, Boyle's law is a law for ideal gases (that can be applied somewhat correctly to real gases). It can't be applied to solids, it can't be applied to liquids, it can't be applied to a photon gas, it can't be applied to black holes. Trying to apply it to black holes shows a completely lack of understanding of the subject.
In particular:
> Is volume, which is length times area, really length times entropy?
What? First the entropy of a black hole is not equal to the area, it's only proportional to the area, there are some constants. (I had to look up S = A * c^3 / 4Għ.) Second, you can't pick any three length [1] and multiply them and expect that the result that has the units of a volume can be used in any formula you want.
[1] For example, the height of the Eiffel tower, the atomic radio of an iron atom in the Eiffel tower and the width of the door of the elevator of the Eiffel tower. You can multiply them and get a volume, but this volume doesn't follow the Boyle's law when the atmospheric pressure changes in Paris.
- reallydude 7y ago> No. It is posible to define the entropy of an object that has no internal indivisible parts, for example a black hole How? If there is no system of parts, there is no entropy. I'm not sure why you have a "black hole" as an example, when you talk about the entropy of a black hole afterward and it's has not been concluded that black holes violate the second law. You have failed to give an example and I think it's important to at least clarify your statement. > First, Boyle's law is a law for ideal gases (that can be applied somewhat correctly to real gases). It can't be applied to solids, it can't be applied to liquids, it can't be applied to a photon gas, it can't be applied to black holes. He didn't say that Boyle's law applied to black holes. He was expounding on the initial point you objected on. If you have a system of parts, it has a volume. > Trying to apply it to black holes shows a completely lack of understanding of the subject. You're being disingenuous by not even attempting to understand the assertion and then attacking every logical conclusion as if that means something. He has an understanding, even if you think it's wrong. > Is volume, which is length times area, really length times entropy? To your first point, it's semantics when you drop the constants. This isn't some obscure way of speaking and he uses it generously. To your second point, he didn't. This was a generalization of the concept expanded to how you calculate the event horizon of a black hole. A sphere's surface area can be calculated from the length of the radius (ie A=4πr2). (from google) S/V = 3/R 4πr2/Volume = 3/r or Area/3/radius = Volume So the interpretation is volume = Area x 1/length or Area x Length (ie radius) when dealing with the variants. A x c^3 / 4Għ = Entropy (Bekenstein–Hawking formula) and dropping all the invariants (A = E) we get Area = Entropy So the volume of a black hole (given it has entropy) could be the volume of the black hole (Area x Length) = Entropy and since we can get area from Length, we can drop the invariants and we get Length = Entropy with constants and invariant proportions.
- nwallin 7y ago> If there is no system of parts, there is no entropy. Define entropy? Wikipedia says this about entropy: > In statistical mechanics, entropy is an extensive property of a thermodynamic system. It is closely related to the number Ω of microscopic configurations (known as microstates) that are consistent with the macroscopic quantities that characterize the system (such as its volume, pressure and temperature). Entropy expresses the number Ω of different configurations that a system defined by macroscopic variables could assume. The number of possible configurations of a black hole is hilariously large and demands delving into up arrows and beyond. It includes collapsing stellar cores, primordial black holes, neutron stars accreting matter until collapse, merging black holes, kugelblitzes, etc., which all are bizarrely dislike microstatically. Yet the possible macroscopic variables are only three: Mass, angular momentum, and charge. If you pretend quantum mechanics don't exist, sure, black holes don't have entropy. But we're pretty sure something that looks a lot like quantum mechanics does exist.
- ziotom78 7y agoMoreover, entropy can be defined using either thermodynamics or statistical mechanics. In the first case (which was the first to be developed, historically) the entropy exists for any isolated system in thermal equilibrium, even though the system can be subdivided into parts or not.
- gus_massa 7y agoThe Area is not equal to the Entropy, it's only proportional. I think we agree about that. From there you deduct in the last paragraph that "Length = Entropy". I guess you want to use the radius or diameter of the black hole (and ignore a few more numerical constants). It doesn't make any sense, they aren't equal, they aren't proportional. The first error is that at some point you use that the volume is "equal" (proportional?) to the entropy, but this relation is wrong. The second error is that in "(Area x Length) = Entropy" you can replace Area by Length^2, and get Length^3 = Entropy. You say that "we can drop the invariants" and you drop the exponent 3, and you get "Length = Entropy", but now you are removing and exponent, not a multiplicative constant. So the "=" is not "equal", is not "proportional", it is only "somewhat related".
- raattgift 7y agoI thought perhaps the confusion comes from seeing things in geometrized units c=G=hbar=1 and losing track in dimensional analysis, but now I think that's too charitable and you're right. Cool whiteboard Penrose diagram though. How one gets to an entropy is ultimately via no-hair. If gravitational multipoles "bald" away in about a horizon light-crossing time, then we have no chance of distinguishing between having formed the black hole from (classically) one collapsing homogeneous spherical shell of neutral dust of mass M (and no angular momentum), or two such shells each of mass M/2 and each with identical-but-differently-signed angular momentum, or three such shells whose mass sums to M and whose angular momenta sum to zero, and so on. The shell count and the details of their individual angular momenta are "lost" from the black hole. The spacetime-filling metric tensor encodes all of this into something that far from the infalls of these shells everything looks like Schwarzschild far from the central mass. This is a bit frustrating if the shells of dust are eternally present, because it doesn't give a strong hint about an observer -- who is far from the central mass at all times -- should slice up spacetime so that the metric is time-dependent. (Breaking the maximal symmetries of the black hole at some point can, though, but we are avoiding that by using these classical shells: if we choose an observer who is sufficiently far away from the shells then at all times they look pointlike (or more precisely always like a central spherically symmetric uncharged mass that is the sum of the black hole and all the shells we throw in, and the observer struggles to determine whether all the mass is within the Schwarszchild radius)). The frustration arises because we can construct the situation so that for a far future observer there is no way to observe how many of these shells were in that observer's distant past, nor what their individual masses, momenta, and charges were: only that all that remains is a nonzero mass, zero angular momentum, and zero charge occupying such a small solid angle of the observer's sky that the observer concludes it is a black hole. The Boltzmannian macrostate is the black hole and its mass, angular momentum and spin; the microstates are the details of the shells, starting with their individual macrostates (each shell has some mass, angular momentum, and charge), and then considering their internal degrees of freedom (dust particles can be of arbitrarily small mass without breaking our spherical-and-homogeneous condition). Thus the "balded" state can have arbitrarily high entropy, because we could have thrown in any number of shells each containing any number of dust particles, because we are in a classical setting where infinitesimals are OK. If we massively increase the particle-mass and reduce the particle number of a shell (constant M>0, J=0, Q=0), we still get the same macrostate compared to arbitrarily lowering particle mass and increasing the particle number to keep the same M>0, J=0, Q=0. If we were to be like Merlin or similar fictional characters and travel with a different arrow-of-time, starting with closer-in view of the black hole as the only thing in the test universe of pure Schwarzschild, we would not be able to predict whether in our personal "future" the black hole will spontaneously spit out one shell of mass M, or two shells each of mass M/2 with an angular momentum summing to 0, or three shells, etc etc. Not being able to predict successor time-indexed spacelike slices of spacetime given the entirety of data on one slice frustrates the initial values approach which works remarkably well in much of physics. (Singularities appear in other physical theories that are far from fundamental, such as Euler/Navier-Stokes fluid dynamics, and they too frustrate initial values studies of systems in which they can arise). ("Initial" is a free choice, and generally means where the physicist starts from, rather than initial as in the sense of in the ultra-distant past. It's fairly common to choose as an initial values surface some final state and work backwards from there.) The quantum picture is a bit more complicated because of the vacuum state problem (I do not have time to get much into that right now[1]) but one can think of throwing in a bunch of neutral hydrogen atoms of mass M versus a bunch of helium atoms of mass M: after "balding", we are again left with only having mass M, angular momentum summing to zero, and no charge: all the quantum information is in the balded black hole. (There are issues about keeping the metric tensor indistinguishable from Schwarzschild in the quantum case; and about how one defines a quantum vacuum). The relevant difference here is that we expect that "Merlin" in the quantum case must only see QFT observables in the stress-energy tensor as he watches the stable black hole spontaneously emit matter, and this is where \hbar comes in in the equation you found. We still think about Boltzmann entropy in the same way though: all the quantum numbers and degrees of freedom in the atoms we throw in result in a no-hair black hole with some mass M, some angular momentum (here we carefully keep it at zero), and some other quantum numbers. The entropy of a black hole is thus extremely high. Sorry that this comment is a bit messy due to lack of time. Also, sorry, I'm not sure when I'll be able to clarify or comment further if needed. - -- [1] (Briefly, some people are unhappier in the quantum case where Merlin cannot predict what QFT observables would appear and when, than in the classical case when he predicts Schwarzschild black hole forever in one arrow-of-time direction, but can't predict shells and shell-components in the other. In particular, the quantum case introduces black hole evaporation, and what gets spit out "spontaneously" in the future does not seem to be what fell in. In the sketch quantum BH above Merlin sees a spitting out of hydrogen or helium atoms, whereas ordinary observer sees an evaporation into mostly just photons (with possibly neutrinos and other massive things in the very late stages of evaporation, but probably never neutral hydrogen or helium atoms (too heavy and too bound during early evaporation, too easy to ionize or transmute during late evaporation)).
- raattgift 7y ago> Chuck a steam engine behind the event horizon. We can’t know anything about it apart from its mass, but I claim it can still do as much work as before. He has only half the "no drama" conjecture here. Given a sufficiently massive Schwarzschild BH the steam engine would work for a while before the Weyl curvature spaghettifies it. As he says a few paragraphs above, the BH area increases when the engine enters the BH. To leading order the increase is driven by the stress-energy of the steam engine, and the stress-energy tensor encodes terms such as chemical and electrostatic potential energy, enthalpy, free energy, internal energy, virial stress, and so forth -- not just mass, although mass tends to dominate in simple systems. At early times the steam engine's entire stress-energy is outside the BH; at later times, the residual stress-energy of the steam engine (having lost some to radiation flying to infinity doing work earlier) is entirely within the horizon. I don't see why he objects to this "saving" of the second law. Also, > It’s all about forgetting information. Well, it's thermodynamics that reveals the forgetting of information because of the classical irreversibility of crossing the horizon (classical BH never shrinks). [Quantum vacuum causes classical black holes to shrink, but the Hawking radiation does not come from inside the black hole; it comes from defining a quantum vacuum as a no-particle state at an early time whereas the (Lorentzian) no-particle condition depends on the metric, and the metric for a collapsing-then-evaporating black hole is time-dependent (M is not eternally the same). By the equivalence principle, we can relate the disagreement between observers about the particle count in a state. In flat spacetime, A's no-particle state may be full of particles for observer B who is accelerated relative to A (this is the Unruh effect); in curved spacetime B who is a region with an event horizon is accelerated relative to A and C who are in regions without an event horizon. Inertial/Eulerian observers A and C may agree that each's "no-particle" vacuum state has no particles; B will see particles in A's "no-particle" vacuum and in C's "no-particle" vacuum. > The system is really the entire space-time Here the author is entirely correct. In the paragraph about no-particle state, the entire spacetime has a region with some nonzero stress-energy localized as a collapsing dust and otherwise everywhere the expectation-value of the stress-energy -- <T> rather than T -- is zero and there are no-particles outside the outermost dust particles. There is another region where there is an event horizon and no dust particles outside it. But there are particles outside and near the horizon, but everywhere far from the horizon <T>=0 and we find no particles there. There is another region where there is no horizon, and an expanding cloud thermal particles with the spectrum of a blackbody radiator that started cold and got extremely hot, but with none of the initial dust particles from the first region, and beyond that a no-particle region. The broad research programme in numerical relativity is to trace the stress-energy tensor (and its generators) through these regions. Unruh discusses this in the context of a sonic analogue of a black hole: https://pos.sissa.it/043/039/pdf https://pos.sissa.it/043/039/pdf