3 ms·
Mugging involves threat of physical harm. Getting ransomeware'd doesn't, and if cities stopped paying then this kind of attack would stop. It's more like outlaw
by arcticbull 7y ago
Mugging involves threat of physical harm. Getting ransomeware'd doesn't, and if cities stopped paying then this kind of attack would stop. It's more like outlawing giving muggers your wallet when you're dressed like Iron Man.
- dmix 7y agoWhat happens if the ransomwares don't stop? Do you spend a bunch of money on investigations to see if some thousands of small towns or little agency somewhere kept if quiet because the cost otherwise is huge? Up the fines the tax payers will pay when they get caught?
- olliej 7y agoI don’t like this argument: if the ransomware takes out emergency dispatch, hospital systems, etc it gets much closer to what you’re claiming.
- vidarh 7y agoThat's assuming attacks that are specifically targeted instead of a scatter approach. If the latter, then it will only stop when the perceived potential for payout worldwide drops low enough.
- tyree731 7y agoI'm not sure why the distinction between physical and virtual harm is relevant. Physical harm is valuable for a person to stop because their life has value to them, and virtual harm is valuable for an organization or person to stop because the virtual assets being harmed have value to the organization or person. We could get into the monetary value of a life and whether a sufficient amount of virtual harm, especially when that virtual harm might reasonably translate into a life (emergency systems, insurance payouts, etc.), but I don't think we even need to.
- istjohn 7y agoThe difference is the mugger gets your wallet one way or the other. The only difference is if you survive to tell the story. The ransomware attacker is only rewarded if the victim capitulates. Edit: On the other hand, if the counter-factual was a mugger at an ATM demanding you enter your PIN, that distinction doesn't exist. So maybe you're right. Maybe the right answer is to outlaw paying the ransom except to save human life, but also create a federal fund to compensate victims of these attacks.