3 ms·
A lot of HN’s electorate’s salaries depend upon not understanding the importance of software freedom. After all, the server we are using to communicate is paid
by sneak 7y ago
A lot of HN’s electorate’s salaries depend upon not understanding the importance of software freedom.
After all, the server we are using to communicate is paid for with dollars made from keeping source code secret from the users of that same software.
Let’s not forget that this is first and foremost a commercial YC project. HN is not free software and its source is not available to its users. It is unsurprising that users here are hostile to the plain, objective fact that it is clearly and self-evidently impossible to own a sequence of bits in the same way one can own a physical object.
- geofft 7y agoMinor point: the source code for this website is available from http://www.arclanguage.org/arc3.2.tar http://www.arclanguage.org/arc3.2.tar (see news.arc) and is free software under the artistic license. Other than that, yes, agreed - despite the name "Hacker News," this forum is run by and for the subset of the hacker community that has a vested interest in monetizing software itself.
- sneak 7y agoIt is my understanding that HN is a fork of that code and is not released.
- geofft 7y agoOh, I definitely assume that, but I'm on the side of "you should be permitted to release / reuse source" and less so on the side of "you should be obligated to release source." (That is, I see software copyright as a thing we should fundamentally not have just like software patents, and I see the GPL's copyleft approach as useful in a world with copyright law and I gladly write GPL software because we live in that world, but I don't think it by itself is justification to retain the leverage of copyright.)