5 ms·
I don't understand what I'm reading here. Why did they offer to pay $400K to recover ~100 PCs if they had backups? Was it so expensive to restore those PCs? I
by wmf 7y ago
I don't understand what I'm reading here. Why did they offer to pay $400K to recover ~100 PCs if they had backups? Was it so expensive to restore those PCs?
I guess the good news is that we can now sell backups as "anti-ransomware" cybersecurity.
- warent 7y agoMaybe they first had to verify the backups actually existed like they should and were up-to-date enough
- everybodyknows 7y agoIndeed. I've worked at a big corp where it was belatedly discovered that backups were broken. A second reason would be to give the attackers reason to pause, in case they somehow had a second bomb to throw, while IT hardened defenses: >Since the attack, the city has installed additional security software and is developing new protocols.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Indeed. I've worked at a big corp where it was belatedly discovered that backups were broken. Ancient wisdom: If you don't test your backups then you don't have any backups.
- frankharv 7y agoMy thoughts exactly. I bet they did not have any backups for the Forth of July weekend so anyone doing city business that weekend may have to redo any paperwork or payments. Small price to pay to laugh at these clowns. What exactly are the FBI doing about this. Perhaps if they got off their asses and quit investigating Presidential piss parties they could find this email recipient. How hard is it for the FBI/NSA to trace an email. They just want to cry about going dark instead. If foreign put a CIA hit on the computer terrorist.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y ago>Why did they offer to pay $400K to recover ~100 PCs if they had backups? "Backup is lets says weekly and someone high up the chain really wants the power point he put together on Tuesday." is probably what happened in my experience.
- beagle3 7y agoWhich sounds ridiculous to me - on Macs you have, available to all users with a reasonable GUI, TimeMachine which is basically hourly backup (though i don’t know if you can make old ones effectively immutable). But if you know how to run a script (and hopefully anyone administering a 100 computer network does), at least on Linux / Mac, you could use bup or borg or a few others to have effective immutable hourly backups that take almost no space - we do that where I work. I’m sure there’s something similar for Windows.
- denkmoon 7y agoThere are such products for Windows, it's even built in. It requires the sysadmin to set it up though, and therefore is non functional in 99% of deployments.
- beagle3 7y agoSnapshots (not incremental nor differential) that take space proportional to change (1 byte change in a 5GB file takes 10K or so in backup, even insertion/deletion), built in to windows? How is it called? TimeMachine in macs has a similar feature set notably lacking proportional space (insert 1 byte anywhere in a 5GB file and the snapshot takes an additional 5GB)
- denkmoon 7y agoCan't say I'm sure about the actual space usage, but the subsystem is "Shadow Copy". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_Copy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_Copy
- userbinator 7y agoI guess the good news is that we can now sell backups as "anti-ransomware" cybersecurity. Backup software has been touted as protection from malware and cyberattacks for a very long time.
- SenHeng 7y agoExcept now there is a more visible dollar sign attached to it. Before, it was hand-wavy what-if scenarios, now you can actually point at real world examples.
- jonknee 7y ago> "I decided to make a counter-offer using insurance proceeds in the amount of $400,000, which I determined to be consistent with ransoms recently paid by other municipalities," Mayor Mitchell said during a press conference (image above). "The attacker declined to make a counter-offer, rejecting the city's position outright." Because that's what they had an insurance policy for.
- secabeen 7y agoJust because they made a counter-offer doesn't mean they intended to actually send the money to a criminal.
- msmerberry 7y agoRight? I saw the line above about giving away taxpayer money. Um...no, only in that while the money originated from taxes, it actually paid to hedge against risk (and the cost of insuring up to 400k is probably significantly less than that amount - what are we talking, several thousand dollars a year MAX of taxpayer money? Worth it!)
- canadaduane 7y agoI think the next paradigm shift is going to be state-synchronization algorithms that make it easy to be eventually-consistent across many peers, all while keeping data encrypted end-to-end. The threat of a data ransom disappears when centralized server role is de-emphasized, and participants all have copies of their data/work (and potentially others' data/work, encrypted).
- auslander 7y ago> if they had backups? I would put a delay in ransomware so it sneaks in weekly and monthly backups, and only then trigger it. If stuff gets restored, sneaked warez will activate again. I bet backups are overwritten after several months.
- beagle3 7y agoSuch a thing is likely to happen but it is much more target specific (e.g. my office backs up data, not code, so you would have to find something scripted that’s in use for that to work on my office) so it will likely happen only if the Low hanging fruits (generic attacks that need much less customization) aren’t lucrative anymore.
- auslander 7y ago> my office backs up data, not code No user's apps? No Registry? Ok, sneak it in Word document then. This delay thing can be applied wholesale, not targeted.
- beagle3 7y agoeverything is backed up for reference, but only data is ever restored. Macro execution is supposed to be disabled on Word/Excel, though I trust that less (and there’s always the issue of some unpatched/zeroday); however, to go through here is more expensive for attackera because much more individual targeting and customization is required.
- auslander 7y agoGood practice. I'm just playing around, devil's advocate.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoIt is difficult to imagine people who are heavy Excel users being ok with macros being disabled wholesale.