8 ms·
Want to DDOS somebody? Try their password incorrectly three times. Stupidest password rule ever. Rate limiting after 3 mis-attempts is understandable. That rat
by exabrial 7y ago
Want to DDOS somebody? Try their password incorrectly three times.
Stupidest password rule ever. Rate limiting after 3 mis-attempts is understandable. That rate limit doesn't need to exceed 1m with passwords over 14 characters.
- vortico 7y agoI don't even think rate limiting after 3 mis-attempts makes sense. I regularly can't remember my password and might need 6 attempts. Nobody's going to guess your password after 300 attempts, so make the limit 30 and you're safe.
- RandallBrown 7y agoThis is basically why I started using a password manager. Screw up 1 too many times and you end up in a cycle where you never will remember your password and you'll try the last 3 or 4 you used, eventually locking yourself out again.
- edoo 7y agoThe primary reason you should use a password manager is that you should consider that password insecure at the place you use it. Any sysadmin at a company can grab your password and try it everywhere else you have accounts.
- vonseel 7y agoWhy not use a password manager?
- viraptor 7y agoWhile it doesn't really justify locking accounts, there's an approach to guessing passwords where you have a large list of accounts available and try each with top 10 passwords, then top 100. Given enough accounts, some will work. (Password spraying) so even limiting to 30 tries wouldn't stop it. Ideally you'd detect one source trying logging into multiple accounts with many failures instead.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoYup. Long ago, a high level person was fired. After that someone hit everybody's passwords enough to trigger account locks. It could only be fixed at the console.
- cjslep 7y agoMy mortgage's website does this rate limiting... by setting a cookie client side. I just close and reopen an incognito window and voila, no more rate limiting.
- js2 7y agoI accidentally DDOS'ed myself creating my ssa.gov account and now I'm pretty sure I've got to visit a physical SSA office with identification to create the account.