2 ms·
It took me a minute not to see this as bad for security, rather than good. But it essentially makes the device you install it on (and register with GH or whatev
by OJFord 7y ago
It took me a minute not to see this as bad for security, rather than good. But it essentially makes the device you install it on (and register with GH or whatever site) a 'trusted device', better than not using U2F at all, worse than a separate hardware key.
I prefer to do the device trusting with Firefox's login manager, and then the second factor is a hardware PGP key where supported, or TOTP on another device if not. Whereas with this the device is trusted with the 'second', so you probably want to store the 'first factor' passwords separately (i.e. have to enter them) for anything important.
- Fnoord 7y agoWhile it is arguably better than nothing (as it at least protects better against brute force attacks, and password leaking) there's a downside to projects like these (and the leaking of passwords could be mitigated by any decent password manager, ie. don't reuse passwords). Services such as websites assume and grant trust levels based on if you have 2FA enabled (such as requiring 2FA for certain operations). Instead, if you don't use hardware 2FA, they shouldn't grant the same level of trust as when you do. The example of malware is mentioned in the README. The secondary reason I use 2FA is stolen device. I keep my hardware token separate from my device when I don't use my device. Also, the README does not mention FIDO2 at all. IIRC that had further protections against malware, but I'm not sure. The README is out of date regardless.
- Terretta 7y agoIt’s interesting the issues thread sees no upside to requiring a specific fingerprint from outside the device (together with the device and the password): https://github.com/github/SoftU2F/pull/29 https://github.com/github/SoftU2F/pull/29 I would prefer a fingerprints change equates to loss of hardware key. I quit sessions, and would like the stronger mitigation of various password bypasses and priv escalations.