12 ms·
We should separate what the tech can do in theory, and what the tech in practice can do. In theory, cryptocurrency can probably do this. Even as someone who is
by vorpalhex 7y ago
We should separate what the tech can do in theory, and what the tech in practice can do.
In theory, cryptocurrency can probably do this. Even as someone who is extremely critical of cryptocurrency and blockchains, this is actually one of the few use cases in which it makes sense - "Hey Bob, I want to buy a business license online. If I give you a $20, can you give me some bitdollars?"
On the other hand, this probably won't work out in practice. Cryptocurrency exchanges do fall under KYC, so the documentation burden still exists. The unbanked could build their own exchange... if they had the capital. In addition, the high level of technical complexity and the need to trust in the unseen (proof of work stakes aren't as good as physical bills when it comes to trust) means the benefits are negated compared to just using the grey market to have someone transact on your behalf (which is a common practice for the unbanked, and also my uncle who still doesn't understand Amazon).
Someone could solve these problems, but they'd need to maintain an ongoing company to do so, which would again trigger KYC and downstream fees.
- brycehamrick 7y agoCryptocurrency exchanges do fall under KYC in the US and only if you want to do certain things, like purchases over a certain volume or fiat withdraws. There's no reason someone in India, for example, would need to go through a KYC process simply to buy a small amount of cryptocurrency. There's also plenty of P2P networks like LocalBitcoins that fit this use case much better than an exchange.
- umeshunni 7y ago> There's no reason someone in India, for example, would need to go through a KYC process simply to buy a small amount of cryptocurrency. Except for local laws which explicitly require KYC for crypto transactions: https://bitcoin-india.org/kyc_aml_policy https://bitcoin-india.org/kyc_aml_policy
- brycehamrick 7y agoThat appears to be one exchanges policy, not law. There may be a law I'm unaware of but in any case this wouldn't come into play using something like LocalBitcoins. Exchanges need to do this in order to conduct transactions with banks—obviously something that isn't needed for unbanked populations.
- lawn 7y agoYou're not wrong, but LocalBitcoins will also require KYC now.