2 ms·
Maybe this is a problem with terminology then; because these definitions are clearly distinct and have entirely separate methods when you formalize them in math
by epistasis 7y ago
Maybe this is a problem with terminology then; because these definitions are clearly distinct and have entirely separate methods when you formalize them in math.
Perhaps we should call Pearl's Rung 3 counterfactuals "subjunctive" or something entirely else to distinguish the concepts and methods of Rung 2 and Rung 3. But these rungs are extremely different in formulations and models, and are clearly distinct. If you want to call rung 2 "simple counterfactuals," well I'm not super into that sort of debate as long as we all agree to the meaning of the terms. And if philosophy finds the distinction between Pearl's Rung 2 and Rung 3 difficult to accept, then it may also mean that philosophy has not yet discovered what Pearl has formulated.