4 ms·
While Athens was not selecting ballots, but representatives directly, random ballot voting[1] is related and is one of a very few voting systems in which strate
by aidenn0 7y ago
While Athens was not selecting ballots, but representatives directly, random ballot voting[1] is related and is one of a very few voting systems in which strategic voting (voting for other than your preferences in order to get the desired outcome) is never correct.
There are systems that make strategic voting not correct in most (if not all) real-world settings, but those are so complicated that IMO strategic voting would still happen just because people don't understand the system.
I would love to see random ballot voting for electing any sufficeintly large set of representatives, it's simple and provides proportional representation.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Random_ballot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Random_ballot
- Spellman 7y agoNon-determinism isn't great though. It could be useful to allocate a number of seats, but then deciding who filled those seats would be a matter of headache (or "trust the party!" goes into effect and removes direct voting)
- wolfgang42 7y agoDeterminism can be readily added by means of a simple procedure (the name of which I have forgotten—hopefully a fellow commenter can chime in here): Along with their vote, each voter submits a random number between 1 and N, where N is the number of voters. To select which ballot should decide the vote, all numbers are publicly revealed and added together, modulo N: the resulting number selects which ballot should be used. It is not possible for any individual or group to fix the final number in advance, since even a single non-cooperating individual can alter the final number in an arbitrary way. Obviously this simple form can only be used if N is known in advance, but I think that if you instead select a sufficiently large maximum (several times larger than the probable N) the randomness property should remain.
- aidenn0 7y agoI'm not sure I understand "deciding who filled those seats would be a matter of headache" you just pick a random ballot and whomever is written on the ballot gets the seat. Repeat for each seat (possibly by district).
- dillondoyle 7y agoI've never heard of this! What about seniority or as HN might call it 'institutional knowledge'? 60% 'safe' seat that used to be held by same Member for life, now 4 out of 10 times is not. And how do you solve for problems with crazy people or super super extreme. Even in a large body like the US House, one member can do a decent amount of damage.
- aidenn0 7y ago> And how do you solve for problems with crazy people or super super extreme. Even in a large body like the US House, one member can do a decent amount of damage. Yes, the specifics of the parliamentary procedure used would have to be adjusted so that a single bad actor can't dominate the whole body. OTOH I've seen a single bad actor in smaller systems (think HOA[1] board) get controlled fairly easily with Robert's rules and a professional parliamentarian. > What about seniority or as HN might call it 'institutional knowledge'? 60% 'safe' seat that used to be held by same Member for life, now 4 out of 10 times is not. Some people think of this as a feature rather than a bug; there is a long history of suspicion of career politicians. I'm not so sure myself, as there is something to institutional knowledge. You could solve this by having every region elect N representatives and each ballot list N candidates in order of preference. At N=4 a 60% popular politician would be elected 98% of the time. At N=2 a 60% popular politician could expect to serve for 2 terms over 70% of the time, which is in keeping with some suggested term limits. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeowner_association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeowner_association
- dillondoyle 7y agohaha look at Ted Cruz ;) !! though perhaps Senate isn't a big enough body I can find examples in the House too yeah no one polls as bad as Congress, but I don't want some 'randomly' chosen Freshman as Speaker. I've found that Reps that have actually competitive races are by far the most responsive by necessity to their District and I think that's a better 'fix' than this proposal.