5 ms·
I like the review, but the criticism of distinguishing causality from counterfactual reasoning feels weak to me. Do we actually care about the counterfactual re
by epistasis 7y ago
I like the review, but the criticism of distinguishing causality from counterfactual reasoning feels weak to me. Do we actually care about the counterfactual reasoning most? Of course. But establishing causality as its own thing before counterfactuals is necessary in the way that Pearl has structured his math. And even the grammar of human languages enforces this separation of concepts. Do you need causality to even have the concept of counterfactual? Of course. Is there value in describing that causality before going on to counterfactuals? Yes I think so, because of the difficulties of current counterfactual algorithms.
Separating out causality opens the door to doing counterfactual reasoning in better ways. Since whatever method is in the Book of Why confused the reviewer, it's probably not the best way to look at counterfactuals, so the causality bits can be taken without establishing the counterfactual methods as the be-all end-all.
For that matter, DAGs versus cyclic directed graphs or time-based DAGS is still a big concern too. Many if not most of our causal reasoning will have loops, when time is not accounted for, and DAG formulations make this difficult to unroll. There may be big improvements in causal modeling, without considering the counterfactuals even.
Also, in Pearl's prior 2000 book on Causality, it's clear that Pearl gave plenty of credit to Spirtes, and it always seemed that they were working in parallel and on very similar problems; I'm not sure how much Spirtes took from Pearl, but Pearl makes clear that his ideas are heavily informed by Spirtes' work.
- empath75 7y agoI am not sure how to define "cause" without introducing counterfactuals. "This happened because I did that" seems to imply "Had I not done that, this would not have happened" -- a counterfactual.
- entropicdrifter 7y agoI'm not sure that's always the case. Couldn't you have a scenario where your action was the direct cause of an outcome that might have come about some other way without your involvement at all? For instance, if a ball rolls down a hill because you pushed it, but a breeze blows a moment after you pushed the ball, if that breeze was strong enough to push the ball down the hill too, then you have a scenario where "that ball went down the hill because I pushed it" is true, but "had I not pushed the ball, it would not have rolled down this hill" is not true.
- skybrian 7y agoYes, what you're describing is basically an "or" gate. The counterfactual is "what if neither cause happened?"
- shkkmo 7y agoright, but the potential existence of multiple potential causes (an "or" gate) is what makes this reasoning a fallacy: > "This happened because I did that" seems to imply "Had I not done that, this would not have happened" -- a counterfactual. The point is that constructing the counterfactual requires a more than just knowledge of a single causal link, but a broader set of causal knowledge about many causal links. Language is messy and ambiguous and we do often colloquially use "X caused Y" to imply the truth of the counter factual "If X had not happened Y would not have happened". Interestingly, a different tense such as "X causes Y" generally does not have the same counter factual implication.
- hyperpape 7y agoYou're 100% correct. The point isn't just about causality. As an undergraduate, one of my philosophy professors (Bill Lycan) told a class "never attempt to define anything in terms of counterfactuals. No matter what it is, there will be decisive counterexamples." To be super-clear, this is not a statement about Pearl, and it's not denying that counterfactuals are interesting, just a claim that you can't define much of anything in terms of them. P.S. He actually said "analyze", but the way philosophers use that term, it's appropriate to make the substitution to avoid confusion.
- ssivark 7y agoThat seems like an unintentional straw man. The actual counterfactual is: "had I not pushed the ball, it would not have rolled down this hill [at the moment it did]". That says nothing about whether some other cause could not push the ball over at a later instant. Equivalently (if you don't like separating out the causes in time), if formulated as an OR operation on a bunch of causes, the counter factual would be: "Had I not pushed the ball, either the ball would not have rolled down the hill, or there would have been another cause for pushing it down the hill."
- epistasis 7y agoMaybe this is a problem with terminology then; because these definitions are clearly distinct and have entirely separate methods when you formalize them in math. Perhaps we should call Pearl's Rung 3 counterfactuals "subjunctive" or something entirely else to distinguish the concepts and methods of Rung 2 and Rung 3. But these rungs are extremely different in formulations and models, and are clearly distinct. If you want to call rung 2 "simple counterfactuals," well I'm not super into that sort of debate as long as we all agree to the meaning of the terms. And if philosophy finds the distinction between Pearl's Rung 2 and Rung 3 difficult to accept, then it may also mean that philosophy has not yet discovered what Pearl has formulated.
- longtom 7y agoNo, these two statements are not equivalent. Perhaps what you have in mind is the contrapositive "This didn't happen, so I didn't do it". More formally, A -> B is equivalent to -B -> -A, but it is not equivalent to -A -> -B.
- mark_l_watson 7y agoI have only read part of this book, so far. I think counter factual reasoning or thought experiments are fundamental to the way we humans think about the world.
- epistasis 7y agoAs I understand it, that counterfactual reasoning is fundamental to human thought seems to be one of the main motivating factors of Pearl's entire causality push, and precisely why it's not OK to ignore causality in science and statistics and machine learning.
- rocqua 7y agoThe DAG, directed graph, or time based DAG question is quite interesting. It seems to me though that time is so interwoven with causality that it is superfluous to include it. Hence, at a glance, I would argue for normal Directed graphs (allowing cycles) with the implicit understanding that following edges means time increases
- mannykannot 7y agoI am not sure Maudlin's example of counterfactual causal reasoning is counterfactual -- though, for all I know, it might be rung-three causal reasoning by Pearl's definition. All the subject seems to be doing is searching the tree of possible outcomes in order to select the most desirable one. She could only say “had I let go of the lamp it would have shattered” after having chosen an alternative course of action and then done it, and by then, of course, it can have no causal role in the decision-making.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoThe key is between hume rejection and data only, there are spectrum of links. Double bind rct ...