3 ms·
This isn't all that reassuring because it's easy enough to record license plates and figure out who they belong to later. It's like the bad ways of releasing an
by skybrian 7y ago
This isn't all that reassuring because it's easy enough to record license plates and figure out who they belong to later. It's like the bad ways of releasing an "anonymized" dataset that differential privacy is supposed to fix.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoBut again, that's only a problem if you've recorded the plates in the first place. Cameras functioning for live-only view with no recording storage, cameras without a good angle of the front or rear of cars or without the adequate zoom level for readability, or radar-based solutions are all incapable of violating your privacy in a meaningful way.
- joshuamorton 7y agoAll of these are based on trusting the owner of the cameras to not do bad things (they could start recording. How would you know?). Which is no better than with differential privacy (you're trusting them to apply these protections when they say they do). How do you know the cameras aren't recording? How do you know the resolution isn't lowered before being made public? How do you know there aren't other cameras that aren't made public? If you're going to use a threat model that assumes malice on a "trusted" organization, you should do so for all such organizations: whether they be google or a government. It's only if you assume google isn't trustworthy, but governments are, that your threat model makes sense. If you don't make that particular set of assumptions (and even if you do in many cases!) differential privacy is a net win.
- ocdtrekkie 7y ago> they could start recording. How would you know? FOIA. That falls into the whole part where government has checks and balances that Google does not.
- joshuamorton 7y agoSo you trust the foia process? How many years do you have? How much money? Do you know the right questions to ask? How are those FOIA requests for stingray usage and tracking information going? Still blocked, last I checked. Like I keep saying: these arguments only work if you assume that the usg is all sunshine and rainbows, which is a naive assumption to make. If you're willing to call NetPAC bad, which you do, you've got to agree that it's only bad if the people taking money do so and support the $badthings you claim google does, by not outlawing them. But if they're corrupt enough to do that, why aren't they corrupt enough to torpedo a few FOIA requests? To put it another way if google is so bad, and you can't even get the USG to police google, how can you expect them to police themselves?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThe government doesn't "police themselves", the system of checks and balances ensures one branch polices another. For instance: The courts have routinely shut down law enforcement agencies' attempts to misuse camera recordings. This was a recent story I read: https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling-demonstrates-evolving-fourth-amendment-rights/ https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling... Meanwhile, Google hid Dragonfly from the internal team that was supposed to review it's projects for ethics issues. And it was pressure from journalists, and then the US Congress that inevitably forced Google to shut it down. Thankfully, despite NetPAC, it looks like enforcement for Google is finally coming. The hand of justice moves slow, unfortunately, but it eventually gets there.
- joshuamorton 7y ago> Meanwhile, Google hid Dragonfly from the internal team that was supposed to review it's projects for ethics issues. And it was pressure from journalists No. It was pressure from employees, employees who had ethical concerns. Employees who, I'll note, you consistently badmouth for continuing to work at Google. It's not like a journalist just magically inferred that Dragonfly was a thing one day and wrote an article one day. And Congress had almost nothing to do with it, lmao. > The government doesn't "police themselves", the system of checks and balances ensures one branch polices another That's true for things that aren't FOIA. But you mentioned FOIA. Which exists as a way for the executive to police themselves. The courts do exist as a check on the executive, (and local governments). So again, how are those stingray FOIA requests going? Note also that "law enforcement" is an FOIA exemption. > This was a recent story I read: https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling.. https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling.... This was a targeted piece of tracking that requires a warrant. Dragnet monitoring often does not require a warrant. In other words, setting up a single camera to monitor a single house needs a warrant. Setting up a hundred cameras to monitor the public doesn't, although getting data from them to target a specific person might, at least if it was being used to imprison them. When was the last time Google imprisoned anyone again? It's also really, really amusing to see you claim that Google is subject to no public accountability. There are absolutely ways you could try to hold Google accountable, if you actually think that they've done something wrong. You just need to be able to convince a Judge. Same as for the executive branch of the government.