3 ms·
Wow, Googlers in full force today. This isn't a market that needs to be powered. This is a market that needs to be shut down. Targeted advertising is inherentl
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
Wow, Googlers in full force today.
This isn't a market that needs to be powered. This is a market that needs to be shut down. Targeted advertising is inherently harmful to society.
- summerlight 7y agoWell, the problem here is that the market doesn't agree with you so it exists. I don't want to argue on the topic of justice (which is pretty subjective), but your argument should give a rationale what is the value of following your solution and why it is more beneficial to the society with an objective measures instead of giving a groundless dogmatic assertion.
- blub 7y agoMarkets are amoral and should not be used to justify anything. You're essentially arguing that something is beneficial to society because it makes money (mostly for Google).
- eclipxe 7y agoThat's your opinion. Not everyone shares that opinion. Advertising has its place in society - as a revenue stream for publishers, as a way to build awareness of a product or service. Just because you personally don't like something, doesn't mean it is harmful to society.
- blub 7y agoThis is not a matter of opinion and focusing on advertising is a red herring, because Google is not just doing advertising, it's using mass surveillance in order to target advertising: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism Surveillance capitalism is harming privacy and the idea of a free society. It gives the people holding the collected information massive power over others.
- eclipxe 7y agoNo, it is absolutely a matter of opinion. This is your opinion. Doesn't mean that it is fact.
- blub 7y agoFrom the way you're brandishing the word opinion, you must be using it with it meaning of "a view about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge", in an attempt to discredit my statements. That's not the case, my view is based on facts: 1. According to their own privacy policy, Google is collecting data to "provide personalized services, including content and ads". 2. This privacy policy applies to all their services, which are used by billions of people. According to the same policy, the data includes search terms, watched videos, content and ads which are seen and interacted with, speech and audio data, purchases, contacts, activities on 3rd party platforms which use Google services, Chrome history, etc. They also collect phone call info including caller and receiver, etc. 3. Google's data collection practices have been investigated by several organizations. Here are some quotes: "As demonstrated throughout this chapter, the ways that Google has designed its Location History and Web & App Activity settings are problematic in light of European data protection requirements. In this report we have questioned the legal basis Google has for collecting and processing this location data. It is questionable whether users have given free, specific, informed, and unambiguous consent to the collection and use of location data through Location History. It can also be discussed whether the user can withdraw his or her consent, since there is no real option to turn off Location History, only to pause it." - Norwegian consumer council. "The combination of privacy intrusive defaults and the use of dark patterns nudge users of Facebook and Google [...] toward the least privacy options to a degree that we consider unethical". - Norwegian consumer council They were already fined by CNIL for GDPR violations and are under investigation in other countries. The FTC has been corrupted by tech lobbying, but a long time ago they did take notice of Google: "FTC Charges Deceptive Privacy Practices in Googles Rollout of Its Buzz Social Network".
- wayneftw 7y ago> This isn't a market that needs to be powered. This is a market that needs to be shut down. Targeted advertising is inherently harmful to society. That's an opinion. That's the whole comment that the person you're replying to said was an opinion. And it is. > ...in an attempt to discredit my statements. Nope. He wasn't even talking to you or about your statements. You tried to do the same thing to me that you're trying to doing here, in another thread. You said that people "repeatedly" told me something when I actually just had made one comment in the thread at that point. What's your deal?
- dang 7y agoYou've crossed the line. Please stop. I replied further at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20890092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20890092. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20888273 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20888273.