3 ms·
People don't understand Myers-Briggs. The scientific experiments all test against questionnaire results, which are admittedly pretty useless. But the theory pos
by nicoburns 7y ago
People don't understand Myers-Briggs. The scientific experiments all test against questionnaire results, which are admittedly pretty useless. But the theory posits internal mechanisms, and nobody has determined a reliable to measure this yet (except expert-guided self-assessment - which is pretty reliable, but generally disregarded by researchers). And most of the studies don't even use this model, and fallback to a frankly ridiculous trait model.
The two fundamental distinctions made by the theory are introversion/extraversion and "judgement"/"perception" aka rational/irrational which remarkably similar to Dual-process theory's System 1 and System 2 thinking (as popularised by Daniel Kahneman's Thinking Fast and Slow).
Both of these models have a ton of experimental evidence validating them. Myers-Briggs just needs a reformulated hypothesis that removes all the Jungian jargon, and explicitly puts it in these terms. When that happens, and with advances in neuroscience, the flood gates for evidence for Myers-Briggs will open.
I wrote my undergraduate dissertation on this topic, and I'm vaguely planning to turn it into a book at some point.
- aidenn0 7y agoI'd be interested in your response to the criticism that MBPI assigns binary categories to things that are largely normally distributed?
- Glyptodon 7y agoFor whatever reason I had multiple teachers in K12 who thought MBPI was a fun thing to do in class (not sure why) (really, I even had a teacher in college think that after it'd been somewhat been debunked) and I remember at least one of the times I did it showing scores for each category on an axis rather than just telling you your "type." Which finally revealed to me why I seemed to switch between J and P randomly when taking it: mine was just barely over the middle in one direction on the J/P score and I finally realized "oh, no wonder it changes, I'm right in the middle." And then I realized it put you solidly in a category when you were only one point away from being in a different one and thought "this is kind of ridiculous."
- cagenut 7y agoI took my first MBTI test by running mbti.exe on my 386's DOS command prompt. After answering all the questions it gave me a score on a 10 point scale for each letter. So for instance I scored an 8 on the Introversion/Extroversion scale, but only a 6 on the iNtuition/Sensing scale. As such when I read the ensuing results/profile information I would always check INTP and ISTP knowing that i personally fell somewhere inbetween. That had to be somewhere in the mid 90s. The four letter code has only ever been about having a conversational starting point, it has never been a binary thing. Anyone that ever said (like this article, or your comment) made that up in their head and then projected it on the world around them. Very INxJ behavior ;)
- aidenn0 7y agoFWIW the parent comment replies in more detail in a different thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20888435 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20888435
- nicoburns 7y agoThe MBTI assigns binary categories to 8 thinking processes. It then posits that people have an ordered preference for using those 8. But the degree to which they prefer 1 versus another leaves plenty of room for a normal distribution by the time we get to the level of describing a person's personality.
- thanatropism 7y ago> But the theory posits internal mechanisms, and nobody has determined a reliable to measure this yet That's the generalized problem with psychoanalysis. It rings true, but lies outside Popperian lines. It's not science in the contemporary sense. Then again, psychology within Popperian lines isn't doing so great. My hot take is that modern psychology's problem is not about overemphasizing biology or anything like that -- it's that it tries to be "enhanced behaviorism": start from what's most superficial and apparent and try to find e.g. what's the molecule of love or the rational (cognitive therapy) way of dealing with depression. Physics got where it is by postulating general principles (e.g. conservation of energy) from shreds of evidence. To do this with psychology takes you outside Popperian lines.
- qubex 7y agoI think your use of ‘problem’ subtends a subtle bias. We tend to take ‘science’ as the golden standard of knowledge, and I’m all for that, but when dealing with human cognitiuon it kind of breaks down anyway because we find ourselves dealing with qualia sooner or later anyway. Expecting falsifiability at the basis of the the cognitive pyramid is, at least for the foreseeable non-cyberpunk future, a bit of a stretch.
- thanatropism 7y agoMy recent comment history has some gushing about Lacan. I might be a fool but I'm not that scientistic strawman.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIn the case of qualia, whilst we cannot make direct measurements, we can make indirect measurements, most especially of behaviour in response to some stimulus or phenomenon. Though that can also go poorly. Microeconomics is based on the foundation of the qualia of utility, as an example. Which presents numerous problems.
- ichbinabe 7y agoHi would you be willing to share your undergrad dissertation?